| rfc9945.original.xml | rfc9945.xml | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| <?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?> | <?xml version='1.0' encoding='utf-8'?> | |||
| <!DOCTYPE rfc [ | <!DOCTYPE rfc [ | |||
| <!ENTITY nbsp " "> | <!ENTITY nbsp " "> | |||
| <!ENTITY zwsp "​"> | <!ENTITY zwsp "​"> | |||
| <!ENTITY nbhy "‑"> | <!ENTITY nbhy "‑"> | |||
| <!ENTITY wj "⁠"> | <!ENTITY wj "⁠"> | |||
| ]> | ]> | |||
| <?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="rfc2629.xslt" ?> | <?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="rfc2629.xslt" ?> | |||
| <!-- generated by https://github.com/cabo/kramdown-rfc version 1.7.30 (Ruby 3.4. | <!-- generated by https://github.com/cabo/kramdown-rfc version 1.7.30 (Ruby 2.5. | |||
| 8) --> | 9) --> | |||
| <rfc xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude" ipr="trust200902" docName="draft | <rfc xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude" ipr="trust200902" docName="draft | |||
| -ietf-modpod-group-processes-16" category="bcp" consensus="true" submissionType= | -ietf-modpod-group-processes-latest" category="bcp" consensus="true" submissionT | |||
| "IETF" obsoletes="3683, 3934" updates="2418, 9245" tocInclude="true" sortRefs="t | ype="IETF" xml:lang="en" number="9945" obsoletes="3683, 3934" updates="2418, 924 | |||
| rue" symRefs="true" version="3"> | 5" tocInclude="true" sortRefs="true" symRefs="true" version="3"> | |||
| <!-- xml2rfc v2v3 conversion 3.31.0 --> | <!-- xml2rfc v2v3 conversion 3.31.0 --> | |||
| <link href="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes -latest" rel="prev"/> | ||||
| <front> | <front> | |||
| <title>IETF Community Moderation</title> | <title abbrev="IETF Community Moderation">IETF Community Moderation</title> | |||
| <seriesInfo name="Internet-Draft" value="draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-1 | <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="9945"/> | |||
| 6"/> | <seriesInfo name="bcp" value="245"/> | |||
| <author initials="L." surname="Eggert" fullname="Lars Eggert" role="editor"> | <author initials="L." surname="Eggert" fullname="Lars Eggert" role="editor"> | |||
| <organization>Mozilla</organization> | <organization>Mozilla</organization> | |||
| <address> | <address> | |||
| <postal> | <postal> | |||
| <street>Stenbergintie 12 B</street> | <street>Stenbergintie 12 B</street> | |||
| <city>Kauniainen</city> | <city>Kauniainen</city> | |||
| <code>02700</code> | <code>02700</code> | |||
| <country>FI</country> | <country>FI</country> | |||
| </postal> | </postal> | |||
| <email>lars@eggert.org</email> | <email>lars@eggert.org</email> | |||
| <uri><https://eggert.org/></uri> | <uri>https://eggert.org/</uri> | |||
| </address> | </address> | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <author initials="E." surname="Lear" fullname="Eliot Lear" role="editor"> | <author initials="E." surname="Lear" fullname="Eliot Lear" role="editor"> | |||
| <organization>Cisco Systems</organization> | <organization>Cisco Systems</organization> | |||
| <address> | <address> | |||
| <postal> | <postal> | |||
| <street>Richtistrasse 7</street> | <street>Richtistrasse 7</street> | |||
| <city>Wallisellen</city> | <city>Wallisellen</city> | |||
| <code>8304</code> | <code>8304</code> | |||
| <country>Switzerland</country> | <country>Switzerland</country> | |||
| </postal> | </postal> | |||
| <phone>+41 44 878 9200</phone> | <phone>+41 44 878 9200</phone> | |||
| <email>lear@lear.ch</email> | <email>lear@lear.ch</email> | |||
| </address> | </address> | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <date year="2026" month="February" day="09"/> | <date year="2026" month="February"/> | |||
| <area>GEN</area> | ||||
| <workgroup>modpod</workgroup> | ||||
| <abstract> | <abstract> | |||
| <?line 73?> | <?line 75?> | |||
| <!-- [rfced] FYI - This document has been assigned a new BCP number as | ||||
| requested. Please note that we will obsolete RFC 3683, and BCP 83 will be | ||||
| retired (BCPs are not obsoleted). | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <!-- [rfced] FYI - We will do the following when we convert the file to | ||||
| RFCXML: | ||||
| - Capitalize “bcp:” in the document header. | ||||
| - Move the Acknowledgments section to appear before the Authors' Addresses | ||||
| section. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <!-- [rfced] Please insert any keywords (beyond those that appear in | ||||
| the title) for use on https://www.rfc-editor.org/search. --> | ||||
| <!-- [rfced] We suggest updating the text below to clarify that the team will | ||||
| be working with the chairs and administrators to implement the | ||||
| procedures. Please review. | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| That team will develop a set of moderation | ||||
| procedures and facilitate their consistent implementation with chairs | ||||
| and administrators. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| That team will develop a set of moderation | ||||
| procedures and work with the chairs and administrators to facilitate | ||||
| their consistent implementation. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>The IETF community will treat people with kindness and grace, but not endless patience.</t> | <t>The IETF community will treat people with kindness and grace, but not endless patience.</t> | |||
| <t>This memo obsoletes RFCs 3683 and 3934, and it updates RFCs 2418 and 92 45 | <t>This memo obsoletes RFCs 3683 and 3934, and it updates RFCs 2418 and 92 45 by | |||
| establishing a policy for the moderation of disruptive | establishing a policy for the moderation of disruptive | |||
| participation | participation | |||
| across the IETF's various public contribution channels and discussion fora. | across the IETF's various public contribution channels and discussion fora. | |||
| It establishes guardrails | It establishes guardrails | |||
| for moderation and a moderator team. That team will develop a | for moderation and a moderator team. That team will develop a | |||
| set of moderation procedures and facilitate their consistent implementation with | set of moderation procedures and facilitate their consistent implementation with | |||
| chairs and administrators.</t> | chairs and administrators.</t> | |||
| </abstract> | </abstract> | |||
| <note removeInRFC="true"> | ||||
| <name>About This Document</name> | ||||
| <t> | ||||
| The latest revision of this draft can be found at <eref target="https:// | ||||
| larseggert.github.io/draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes/draft-ietf-modpod-group-p | ||||
| rocesses.html"/>. | ||||
| Status information for this document may be found at <eref target="https | ||||
| ://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes/"/>. | ||||
| </t> | ||||
| <t> | ||||
| Discussion of this document takes place on the | ||||
| mod-discuss Working Group mailing list (<eref target="mailto:mod-discuss | ||||
| @ietf.org"/>), | ||||
| which is archived at <eref target="https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/bro | ||||
| wse/mod-discuss/"/>. | ||||
| Subscribe at <eref target="https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/mod-dis | ||||
| cuss/"/>. | ||||
| </t> | ||||
| <t>Source for this draft and an issue tracker can be found at | ||||
| <eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-group-proc | ||||
| esses"/>.</t> | ||||
| </note> | ||||
| </front> | </front> | |||
| <middle> | <middle> | |||
| <?line 85?> | <?line 118?> | |||
| <section anchor="introduction"> | <section anchor="introduction"> | |||
| <name>Introduction</name> | <name>Introduction</name> | |||
| <t>This memo establishes a policy for the moderation of disruptive | <t>This memo establishes a policy for the moderation of disruptive | |||
| participation | participation | |||
| across the IETF's various public online contribution channels and discussion for a. | across the IETF's various public online contribution channels and discussion for a. | |||
| It creates a | It creates a | |||
| moderator team to develop procedures and to facilitate their consistent | moderator team to develop procedures and to facilitate their consistent | |||
| application.</t> | application.</t> | |||
| <t>This memo obsoletes and updates some prior IETF processes, summarized h ere. | <t>This memo obsoletes and updates some prior IETF processes, summarized h ere. | |||
| Background information is described in more detail in <xref target="motivation"/ >.</t> | Background information is described in more detail in <xref target="motivation"/ >.</t> | |||
| <t>This memo makes the following changes to existing processes:</t> | <!-- [rfced] Please review "moderator team replaces the IETF discussion li | |||
| st | ||||
| moderation team" and let us know if any updates would be helpful for clarity. | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| * Obsoletes Section 3 of [RFC9245] and the second paragraph of | ||||
| Section 4 of [RFC9245], as the moderator team replaces the IETF | ||||
| discussion list moderation team. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| * Obsoletes Section 3 of [RFC9245] and the second paragraph of | ||||
| Section 4 of [RFC9245], as the IETF moderator team defined in this documen | ||||
| t | ||||
| replaces the IETF discussion list moderator team. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>This memo makes the following changes to existing processes:</t> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <ul spacing="normal"> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Obsoletes <xref target="RFC3683"/> as the "posting rights" (PR) act ion it defines | <t>Obsoletes <xref target="RFC3683"/> as the "posting rights" (PR) act ion it defines | |||
| are replaced by processes defined herein;</t> | is replaced by processes defined herein;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Obsoletes <xref target="RFC3934"/> as it replaces working group mod eration | <t>Obsoletes <xref target="RFC3934"/> as it replaces working group mod eration | |||
| procedures;</t> | procedures;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Obsoletes <xref section="3" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC9245"/> a nd the second paragraph of | <t>Obsoletes <xref section="3" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC9245"/> a nd the second paragraph of | |||
| <xref section="4" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC9245"/>, as the moderator team r eplaces the | <xref section="4" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC9245"/>, as the moderator team r eplaces the | |||
| IETF discussion list moderation team.</t> | IETF discussion list moderation team.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| skipping to change at line 115 ¶ | skipping to change at line 149 ¶ | |||
| <t>The processes described in this memo are solely applicable to IETF | <t>The processes described in this memo are solely applicable to IETF | |||
| activities, and not to other related organizations, such as | activities, and not to other related organizations, such as | |||
| the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF), | the Internet Research Task Force (IRTF), | |||
| the Internet Architecture Board (IAB), | the Internet Architecture Board (IAB), | |||
| the RFC Series Working Group (RSWG), the RFC Series Approval Board (RSAB), | the RFC Series Working Group (RSWG), the RFC Series Approval Board (RSAB), | |||
| or the Independent RFC Submission Stream, without their explicit agreement. | or the Independent RFC Submission Stream, without their explicit agreement. | |||
| These changes take effect when the procedures described | These changes take effect when the procedures described | |||
| in <xref target="prod"/> have been approved by the IESG.</t> | in <xref target="prod"/> have been approved by the IESG.</t> | |||
| <section anchor="terminology-note"> | <section anchor="terminology-note"> | |||
| <name>Terminology Note</name> | <name>Terminology Note</name> | |||
| <t>Below, the term "administrator" refers to the people who | <t>In this document, the term "administrator" refers to the people who | |||
| are assigned by the IESG to manage a particular public participation | are assigned by the IESG to manage a particular public participation | |||
| channel or discussion forum. This memo uses the term "forum" | channel or discussion forum. This memo uses the term "forum" | |||
| to refer to any public IETF participation channel, such as a mailing list, | to refer to any public IETF participation channel, such as a mailing list, | |||
| chat group, or discussion in a collaborative tool such as GitHub or | chat group, or discussion in a collaborative tool such as GitHub or | |||
| GitLab. For example, working | GitLab. For example, working | |||
| group chairs are administrators of all the public fora that their working groups | group chairs are administrators of all the public fora that their working groups | |||
| use, which typically includes mailing lists and chat groups, but might | use, which typically includes mailing lists and chat groups, but might | |||
| also include collaborative tools such as GitHub or GitLab. Another example | also include collaborative tools such as GitHub or GitLab. | |||
| of administrators are the "owners" of non-WG IETF mailing lists.</t> | The "owners" of non-WG IETF mailing lists are another example of administrators. | |||
| </t> | ||||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="genphil"> | <section anchor="genphil"> | |||
| <name>General Philosophy</name> | <name>General Philosophy</name> | |||
| <t>This policy's cornerstone is that individuals are responsible for | <t>This cornerstone of this policy is that individuals are responsible f or | |||
| furthering the goals of the IETF as an organization <xref target="RFC3935"/> | furthering the goals of the IETF as an organization <xref target="RFC3935"/> | |||
| in a manner consistent with the policy laid out in <xref target="RFC7154"/>.</t> | in a manner consistent with the policy laid out in <xref target="RFC7154"/>.</t> | |||
| <t>Disagreement and diverse points of view within any standards organiza tion | <t>Disagreement and diverse points of view within any standards organiza tion | |||
| are to be expected, and are even healthy. | are to be expected and are even healthy. | |||
| The IETF is an open standards organization with a discussion-based rough | The IETF is an open standards organization with a discussion-based rough | |||
| consensus process, a non-normative description of which is in <xref target="RFC7 282"/>. | consensus process, a non-normative description of which is in <xref target="RFC7 282"/>. | |||
| Engaged, respectful discussion that is within the scope of an IETF forum | Engaged, respectful discussion that is within the scope of an IETF forum | |||
| should therefore not be considered disruptive, | should therefore not be considered disruptive, | |||
| nor should someone be considered disruptive solely because they are outside | nor should someone be considered disruptive solely because they are outside | |||
| the rough consensus. | the rough consensus. | |||
| However, when someone crosses the line | However, when someone crosses the line | |||
| into disruptive behavior, some action must be taken in order to maintain | into disruptive behavior, action must be taken in order to maintain | |||
| decorum of the community.</t> | decorum of the community.</t> | |||
| <t>The moderation policy goals are as follows:</t> | <t>The moderation policy goals are as follows:</t> | |||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <!-- [rfced] We updated this bullet item for parallelism with the rest o | |||
| f the | ||||
| list (i.e., each starts with a verb). Would you like to further update to the | ||||
| suggestion listed under "Perhaps" below? | ||||
| Original (surrounding text provided for context): | ||||
| The moderation policy goals are as follows: | ||||
| * Apply consistent, fair, and timely moderation of communication | ||||
| across all public online IETF participation channels and | ||||
| participation fora without regard to a participant's role in the | ||||
| IETF or previous technical contributions; | ||||
| * Appeals are available to address disagreements about moderation | ||||
| actions; | ||||
| Updated: | ||||
| * Ensure appeals are available to address disagreements about moderation | ||||
| actions; | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| * Ensure an appeals path is available to address disagreements about moderat | ||||
| ion | ||||
| actions; | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Apply consistent, fair, and timely moderation of communication ac ross all public | <t>Apply consistent, fair, and timely moderation of communication ac ross all public | |||
| online IETF participation channels and participation fora | online IETF participation channels and participation fora | |||
| without regard to a participant's role in the IETF or previous technical | without regard to a participant's role in the IETF or previous technical | |||
| contributions;</t> | contributions;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Appeals are available to address disagreements about moderation a ctions;</t> | <t>Ensure appeals are available to address disagreements about moder ation actions;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Balance transparency against both privacy of individuals involved and further | <t>Balance transparency against both privacy of individuals involved and further | |||
| disruption to the community;</t> | disruption to the community;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Allow moderation decisions to be reconsidered; and</t> | <t>Allow moderation decisions to be reconsidered; and</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Provide the broadest possible latitude to all people doing modera tion, so | <t>Provide the broadest possible latitude to all people doing modera tion, so | |||
| that they have the flexibility to address a broad range of individuals | that they have the flexibility to address a broad range of individuals | |||
| and circumstances.</t> | and circumstances.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <t>Questions about processes detailed below should be answered through t | <!-- [rfced] For readability, we suggest the following update. Please r | |||
| he lens | eview. | |||
| Original: | ||||
| Questions about processes detailed below should be answered through | ||||
| the lens of these aims. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| Questions about the processes detailed below should be answered with these | ||||
| goals in mind. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Questions about the processes detailed below should be answered through the l | ||||
| ens | ||||
| of these aims.</t> | of these aims.</t> | |||
| <t>The goal is explicitly <strong>not</strong> punishment, but to mainta | <!-- [rfced] We recommend stating the main point first, as opposed to wh | |||
| in an open, welcoming, | at | |||
| non-hostile environment in which all may participate on an equal footing, | it is not, so we suggest the following update. Please review. | |||
| regardless of their role in the IETF or past technical contributions.</t> | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| The goal is explicitly *not* punishment, but to maintain an open, | ||||
| welcoming, non-hostile environment in which all may participate on an | ||||
| equal footing, regardless of their role in the IETF or past technical | ||||
| contributions. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| The objective is to maintain an open, | ||||
| welcoming, non-hostile environment in which all may participate on an | ||||
| equal footing, regardless of their role in the IETF or past technical | ||||
| contributions; it is explicitly *not* intended as a punishment. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>The objective is explicitly <strong>not</strong> punishment, but to maintain | ||||
| an open, | ||||
| welcoming, non-hostile environment in which all may participate on an | ||||
| equal footing, regardless of their role in the IETF or past technical | ||||
| contributions.</t> | ||||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="ietf-moderator-team"> | <section anchor="ietf-moderator-team"> | |||
| <name>IETF Moderator Team</name> | <name>IETF Moderator Team</name> | |||
| <t>This memo defines a consistent approach to moderating the | <t>This memo defines a consistent approach to moderating the | |||
| IETF's various public online fora. A moderator team for the IETF | IETF's various public online fora. A moderator team for the IETF | |||
| will develop and maintain guidelines for moderation and will facilitate | will develop and maintain guidelines for moderation and will facilitate | |||
| their consistent implementation and application as detailed below. | their consistent implementation and application as detailed below. | |||
| These changes are intended to address the issues identified | These changes are intended to address the issues identified | |||
| in the previous model <xref target="motive"/> and the principles described in th e | in the previous model (see <xref target="motive"/>) and the principles described in the | |||
| introduction.</t> | introduction.</t> | |||
| <section anchor="composition"> | <section anchor="composition"> | |||
| <name>Composition</name> | <name>Composition</name> | |||
| <t>The IESG appoints and recalls moderators. | <t>The IESG appoints and recalls moderators. | |||
| The moderator team initially consists of no fewer than five individuals. | The moderator team initially consists of no fewer than five individuals. | |||
| The moderator team may expand or contract | The moderator team may expand or contract | |||
| based on operational experience. | based on operational experience. | |||
| In selecting members, the IESG will take into | In selecting members, the IESG will take into | |||
| account geographic coverage, expected and unexpected absences, and | account geographic coverage, expected and unexpected absences, and | |||
| team diversity.</t> | team diversity.</t> | |||
| <t>Because the IESG and IAB are in the appeals chain for moderator team | <!-- [rfced] Should "LLC Board" and "LLC staff and contractors" be updat | |||
| ed to | ||||
| "IETF LLC Board" and "IETF LLC staff and contractors" (i.e., include "IETF")? | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| Individuals serving on other | ||||
| bodies to which the NomCom appoints members, such as the IETF Trust | ||||
| or the LLC Board, as well as LLC staff and contractors shall also be | ||||
| excluded from serving on the moderator team. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| Individuals serving on other | ||||
| bodies to which the NomCom appoints members, such as the IETF Trust | ||||
| or the IETF LLC Board, as well as IETF LLC staff and contractors shall also b | ||||
| e | ||||
| excluded from serving on the moderator team. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Because the IESG and IAB are in the appeals chain for moderator team | ||||
| decisions (see <xref target="appeals"/>), the IESG must not appoint a | decisions (see <xref target="appeals"/>), the IESG must not appoint a | |||
| moderator who is serving on the IESG or IAB. Individuals serving on | moderator who is serving on the IESG or IAB. Individuals serving on | |||
| other bodies to which the NomCom appoints members, such as the IETF | other bodies to which the NomCom appoints members, such as the IETF | |||
| Trust or the LLC Board, as well as LLC staff and contractors shall | Trust or the LLC Board, as well as LLC staff and contractors, shall | |||
| also be excluded from serving on the moderator team. If a moderator | also be excluded from serving on the moderator team. If a moderator | |||
| is assuming any such role, they shall step down from the moderator team | assumes any such role, they shall step down from the moderator team | |||
| soon after.</t> | soon after.</t> | |||
| <section anchor="team-diversity"> | <section anchor="team-diversity"> | |||
| <name>Team Diversity</name> | <name>Team Diversity</name> | |||
| <t>Due to the global nature of the IETF, the membership of this team | <t>Due to the global nature of the IETF, the membership of this team | |||
| should reflect a diversity of time zones and other participant | should reflect a diversity of time zones and other participant | |||
| characteristics that lets it operate effectively around the clock and | characteristics that lets it operate effectively around the clock and | |||
| throughout the year. Ideally, the moderators should be able to | throughout the year. Ideally, the moderators should be able to | |||
| respond to issues within a few hours.</t> | respond to issues within a few hours.</t> | |||
| <t>Team diversity is also important to ensure any participant observin | <!-- [rfced] Should this sentence mention those experiencing disruptiv | |||
| g | e | |||
| behavior (not just those observing it)? Also, would updating "is also | ||||
| important to ensure" to "also improves the likelihood" (or similar) improve | ||||
| this sentence? | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| Team diversity is also important to ensure any participant observing | ||||
| disruptive behavior can identify a moderator they feel comfortable | ||||
| contacting. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| Team diversity also improves the likelihood that any participant experiencing | ||||
| or observing disruptive behavior can identify a moderator they feel comfortab | ||||
| le | ||||
| contacting. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Team diversity is also important to ensure any participant observing | ||||
| disruptive behavior can identify a moderator they feel comfortable | disruptive behavior can identify a moderator they feel comfortable | |||
| contacting.</t> | contacting.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="training"> | <section anchor="training"> | |||
| <name>Training</name> | <name>Training</name> | |||
| <t>The IETF is committed to providing and/or funding training for | <t>The IETF is committed to providing and/or funding training for | |||
| administrators and moderators as necessary. The IESG will | administrators and moderators as necessary. The IESG will | |||
| negotiate any required funding or resources with IETF Administration | negotiate any required funding or resources with IETF Administration | |||
| LLC <xref target="RFC8711"/>.</t> | LLC <xref target="RFC8711"/>.</t> | |||
| skipping to change at line 228 ¶ | skipping to change at line 346 ¶ | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="scope-and-responsibilities"> | <section anchor="scope-and-responsibilities"> | |||
| <name>Scope and Responsibilities</name> | <name>Scope and Responsibilities</name> | |||
| <t>This policy applies to all public online IETF fora, both present and | <t>This policy applies to all public online IETF fora, both present and | |||
| future, including, but not limited to, mailing lists, chat groups, | future, including, but not limited to, mailing lists, chat groups, | |||
| and discussions in other systems that the IETF or WGs have chosen to | and discussions in other systems that the IETF or WGs have chosen to | |||
| employ, such as GitHub repositories, wikis, or issue trackers.</t> | employ, such as GitHub repositories, wikis, or issue trackers.</t> | |||
| <t>Different people have different moderation responsibilities:</t> | <t>Different people have different moderation responsibilities:</t> | |||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <ul spacing="normal"> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><strong>Participants</strong> should always behave in a manner disc ussed in | <t><strong>Participants</strong> should always behave in the manner di scussed in | |||
| <xref target="genphil"/>. They are also encouraged to report disruptive behavio r | <xref target="genphil"/>. They are also encouraged to report disruptive behavio r | |||
| directed at them or someone else to an administrator of the respective | directed at them or someone else to an administrator of the respective | |||
| forum <strong>and</strong> the moderators.</t> | forum <strong>and</strong> the moderators.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><strong>Administrators</strong> are primarily responsible for manag ing their fora in | <t><strong>Administrators</strong> are primarily responsible for manag ing their fora in | |||
| accordance with procedures developed by the moderators and approved by | accordance with procedures developed by the moderators and approved by | |||
| the IESG. As such, they shall address reports of disruptive behavior | the IESG. As such, they shall address reports of disruptive behavior | |||
| in a timely fashion, apprising moderators of reports or actions taken. | in a timely fashion, apprising moderators of reports or actions taken. | |||
| Administrators may amend or rescind actions, including those taken by | Administrators may amend or rescind actions, including those taken by | |||
| members of the moderation team <strong>after</strong> they have consulted with t hat team. </t> | members of the moderation team <strong>after</strong> they have consulted with t hat team. </t> | |||
| <t> | <t> | |||
| For a working group, chairs are by default the administrators. They may | For a working group, chairs are by default the administrators. They may | |||
| delegate this responsibility in the same vein as <xref section="6.4" sectionForm at="of" target="RFC2418"/> | delegate this responsibility in the same vein as <xref section="6.4" sectionForm at="of" target="RFC2418"/>, | |||
| but they must always accept, acknowledge, | but they must always accept, acknowledge, | |||
| and keep track of complaints of disruptive behavior. | and keep track of complaints of disruptive behavior. | |||
| Forum administrators should perform moderation in a way that | Forum administrators should perform moderation in a way that | |||
| obviates the need for moderator team involvement.</t> | obviates the need for moderator team involvement.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><strong>Moderators</strong> are responsible for establishing proced ures to | <t><strong>Moderators</strong> are responsible for establishing proced ures to | |||
| address moderation needs across all IETF fora, both present and | address moderation needs across all IETF fora, both present and | |||
| future. They are a resource that the community | future. They are a resource that the community | |||
| can use to address disruptive behavior. | can use to address disruptive behavior. | |||
| The moderator team is responsible to the IESG. The IESG | The moderator team is responsible to the IESG. The IESG | |||
| will create or designate a forum to facilitate discussion about | will create or designate a forum to facilitate discussion about | |||
| moderation, and refer interested parties to that forum. </t> | moderation and refer interested parties to that forum. </t> | |||
| <t> | <t> | |||
| Moderators may take actions when administrators do not respond to | Moderators may take actions when administrators do not respond to | |||
| reports in a timely fashion. Their first action should generally be | reports in a timely fashion. Their first action should generally be | |||
| to attempt to contact and advise the relevant administrators. | to attempt to contact and advise the relevant administrators. | |||
| They should only take | They should only take | |||
| moderation actions when administrators are not responsive, or when | moderation actions when administrators are not responsive or when | |||
| someone disrupts multiple fora at the same time. Moderators should | someone disrupts multiple fora at the same time. Moderators should | |||
| generally give WG chairs the opportunity to | generally give WG chairs the opportunity to | |||
| manage what may be difficult and contentious debates within their | manage what may be difficult and contentious debates within their | |||
| groups. Within the bounds of this principle, it is left to | groups. Within the bounds of this principle, it is left to | |||
| moderators' judgment to determine when they must act, with the | moderators' judgment to determine when they must act, with the | |||
| understanding that some situations may require fast responses. | understanding that some situations may require fast responses. | |||
| Moderators must notify administrators of any actions they take. | Moderators must notify administrators of any actions they take. | |||
| <xref target="appeals"/> discusses the handling of disagreements. </t> | <xref target="appeals"/> discusses the handling of disagreements. </t> | |||
| <t> | <t> | |||
| Moderators are administrators for IETF | Moderators are administrators for IETF | |||
| plenary fora, currently including the IETF discussion and last-call | plenary fora, currently including the IETF discussion and Last Call | |||
| lists and any plenary chat sessions. They are also administrators for | lists and any plenary chat sessions. They are also administrators for | |||
| any forum that does not otherwise have an administrator. </t> | any forum that does not otherwise have an administrator. </t> | |||
| <t> | <t> | |||
| In order to scale the function, except for plenary fora as described | In order to scale the function, except for plenary fora as described | |||
| above, moderators are not expected to always actively monitor | above, moderators are not expected to always actively monitor | |||
| all communications. In general, they will process reports from | all communications. In general, they will process reports from | |||
| participants.</t> | participants.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><strong>Area Directors</strong> are expected to resolve conflicts a s described here and | <t><strong>Area directors</strong> are expected to resolve conflicts a s described here and | |||
| in <xref target="appeals"/>. The IESG will periodically evaluate the performanc e | in <xref target="appeals"/>. The IESG will periodically evaluate the performanc e | |||
| and needs of moderators, and may appoint and recall moderators as | and needs of moderators, and may appoint and recall moderators as | |||
| they deem appropriate. Apart from that, | they deem appropriate. Apart from that, | |||
| the IESG shall refrain from the day-to-day operation | the IESG shall refrain from the day-to-day operation | |||
| and management of the moderator team. The moderators may | and management of the moderator team. The moderators may | |||
| consult with the IESG when needed.</t> | consult with the IESG when needed.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <section anchor="actions-that-are-out-of-scope"> | <section anchor="actions-that-are-out-of-scope"> | |||
| <name>Actions That Are Out of Scope</name> | <name>Actions That Are Out of Scope</name> | |||
| skipping to change at line 307 ¶ | skipping to change at line 425 ¶ | |||
| virtual, or hybrid | virtual, or hybrid | |||
| meeting participation; content removal or redaction; and moderation or | meeting participation; content removal or redaction; and moderation or | |||
| policing of private or non-IETF communications. | policing of private or non-IETF communications. | |||
| While the moderator team does not moderate non-public IETF mailing | While the moderator team does not moderate non-public IETF mailing | |||
| lists, the administrators of such lists can choose to adopt some of the | lists, the administrators of such lists can choose to adopt some of the | |||
| procedures that the moderator team develops.</t> | procedures that the moderator team develops.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="unsolicited-bulk-messages"> | <section anchor="unsolicited-bulk-messages"> | |||
| <name>Unsolicited Bulk Messages</name> | <name>Unsolicited Bulk Messages</name> | |||
| <t>Unsolicited bulk messages are considered disruptive and should be han dled in a | <t>Unsolicited bulk messages are considered disruptive and should be han dled in a | |||
| manner consistent with the IESG statement on IETF Spam Control on IETF | manner consistent with the "IESG Statement on Spam Control on IETF Mailing Lists | |||
| Mailing Lists<xref target="IESG-SPAM"/>, or its successors. Administrators and | " | |||
| moderators | <xref target="IESG-SPAM"/> or its successors. Administrators and moderators | |||
| may take similar actions in other fora (e.g., GitHub or Instant Messaging). | may take similar actions in other fora (e.g., GitHub or instant messaging). | |||
| Such actions require no additional reporting.</t> | Such actions require no additional reporting.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="prod"> | <section anchor="prod"> | |||
| <name>Moderation Procedures and Transparency</name> | <name>Moderation Procedures and Transparency</name> | |||
| <t>Within the bounds of the policies set herein, the moderator team shall develop | <t>Within the bounds of the policies set herein, the moderator team shall develop | |||
| and maintain procedures and criteria relating to moderation, including | and maintain procedures and criteria relating to moderation, including | |||
| the moderator team's own operating procedures.</t> | the moderator team's own operating procedures.</t> | |||
| <t>Those procedures and criteria shall be developed with community input, | <t>Those procedures and criteria shall be developed with community input, | |||
| be approved by the IESG prior to going into effect, | be approved by the IESG prior to going into effect, | |||
| and be made public. However, they need not be documented in the RFC series. Th is | and be made public. However, they need not be documented in the RFC Series. Th is | |||
| shall be the first task for the moderator team. Until | shall be the first task for the moderator team. Until | |||
| those procedures and criteria are established, all previous processes | those procedures and criteria are established, all previous processes | |||
| referenced in <xref target="introduction"/> shall remain in effect.</t> | referenced in <xref target="introduction"/> shall remain in effect.</t> | |||
| <t>The intent of this memo is to provide the widest possible freedom of | <t>The intent of this memo is to provide the widest possible freedom of | |||
| action to administrators and moderators, with the expectation that | action to administrators and moderators, with the expectation that | |||
| the minimal actions necessary will be taken. Those who are directed | the minimal actions necessary will be taken. Those who are directed | |||
| to stop disrupting a forum must do so immediately. | to stop disrupting a forum must do so immediately. | |||
| Further disruptions may lead to further corrective actions.</t> | Further disruptions may lead to further corrective actions.</t> | |||
| <t>Examples of actions that could be taken include:</t> | <t>Examples of actions that could be taken include:</t> | |||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <ul spacing="normal"> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Automated rate limiting mechanisms;</t> | <t>Automated rate-limiting mechanisms;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Review and approval of submissions/messages;</t> | <t>Review and approval of submissions/messages;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>A private or public admonishment;</t> | <t>A private or public admonishment;</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Temporary or indefinite suspension of participation privileges | <t>Temporary or indefinite suspension of participation privileges | |||
| in one or more fora.</t> | in one or more fora.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <t>These are only examples, and not in any way | <t>These are only examples and are not in any way | |||
| prescriptive. Administrators and moderators are free to decide on | prescriptive. Administrators and moderators are free to decide on | |||
| these or other actions.</t> | these or other actions.</t> | |||
| <t>All moderation actions that restrict participation | <t>All moderation actions that restrict participation | |||
| privileges shall be immediately reported to those against | privileges shall be immediately reported to those against | |||
| whom those actions take effect, to relevant administrators, | whom those actions take effect, to relevant administrators, | |||
| and to the moderator team for | and to the moderator team for | |||
| their review. They shall also be periodically reported to | their review. They shall also be periodically reported to | |||
| the IESG.</t> | the IESG.</t> | |||
| <t>Only moderation actions suspending participation privileges for longer | <!-- [rfced] May we update this sentence as follows to improve clarity? | |||
| than | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| Only moderation actions suspending participation privileges for | ||||
| longer than fourteen (14) days must be reported to the forum to which | ||||
| such an action applies, or in any event, at the request of the | ||||
| suspended person. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| At the request of the suspended individual, moderation actions that suspend | ||||
| participation privileges are to be reported to the forum to which such an | ||||
| action applies. Otherwise, only suspensions longer than fourteen (14) days | ||||
| must be reported to the relevant forum. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Only moderation actions suspending participation privileges for longer than | ||||
| fourteen (14) days must be reported to the forum to which such an action applies , | fourteen (14) days must be reported to the forum to which such an action applies , | |||
| or in any event, at the request of the suspended person. | or in any event, at the request of the suspended person. | |||
| If such an action applies to more than one forum, it should be communicated to | If such an action applies to more than one forum, it should be communicated to | |||
| the community in a manner decided by the IESG.</t> | the community in a manner decided by the IESG.</t> | |||
| <t>Moderators will periodically provide an aggregate report to the communi ty on | <t>Moderators will periodically provide an aggregate report to the communi ty on | |||
| actions taken under this policy.</t> | actions taken under this policy.</t> | |||
| <section anchor="appeals"> | <section anchor="appeals"> | |||
| <name>Consistency and Conflict Resolution</name> | <name>Consistency and Conflict Resolution</name> | |||
| <t>Administrators and moderators shall act in a manner | <t>Administrators and moderators shall act in a manner | |||
| consistent with this memo and the guidelines approved by the IESG. In cases | consistent with this memo and the guidelines approved by the IESG. In cases | |||
| of disagreement over a moderation decision, anyone may take the matter up | of disagreement over a moderation decision, anyone may take the matter up | |||
| with the responsible Area Director for resolution, or with the IETF chair | with the responsible area director for resolution, or with the IETF Chair | |||
| if a responsible Area Director cannot be determined or is not assigned. | if a responsible area director cannot be determined or is not assigned. | |||
| If the disagreement cannot be resolved by the Area Director, that person may | If the disagreement cannot be resolved by the area director, that person may | |||
| then appeal to the IESG, and subsequently to the IAB using the processes | then appeal to the IESG and subsequently to the IAB using the processes | |||
| stated in Sections <xref target="RFC2026" section="6.5.1" sectionFormat="bare"/> and <xref target="RFC2026" section="6.5.4" sectionFormat="bare"/> of <xref targ et="RFC2026"/>.</t> | stated in Sections <xref target="RFC2026" section="6.5.1" sectionFormat="bare"/> and <xref target="RFC2026" section="6.5.4" sectionFormat="bare"/> of <xref targ et="RFC2026"/>.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="reinstatement"> | <section anchor="reinstatement"> | |||
| <name>Reinstatement</name> | <name>Reinstatement</name> | |||
| <t>People and circumstances change. Individuals whose participation | <t>People and circumstances change. Individuals whose participation | |||
| privileges have been indefinitely suspended from a forum may request | privileges have been indefinitely suspended from a forum may request | |||
| reinstatement. | reinstatement. | |||
| Requests for reinstatement | Requests for reinstatement | |||
| may be made no earlier than a year after the initial decision, and then | may be made no earlier than a year after the initial decision and then | |||
| only annually afterward.</t> | only annually afterward.</t> | |||
| <t>Any such request must be | <t>Any such request must be | |||
| directed to the entity who made the decision (e.g., moderator team, | directed to the entity who made the decision (e.g., moderator team, | |||
| working group chairs, etc.) or their successors. That party may at | working group chairs, etc.) or their successors. That party may at | |||
| their discretion | their discretion | |||
| reinstate someone, conditionally or unconditionally.</t> | reinstate someone, conditionally or unconditionally.</t> | |||
| <t>To avoid | <t>To avoid | |||
| denial-of-service attacks on IETF processes, decisions to not reinstate | denial-of-service attacks on IETF processes, decisions to not reinstate | |||
| someone's participation privileges may not be appealed. | someone's participation privileges may not be appealed. | |||
| Any reinstatement is a grace and not a right.</t> | Any reinstatement is a grace and not a right.</t> | |||
| <t>A suspension of participation privileges imposed prior to this proces s | <t>A suspension of participation privileges imposed prior to this proces s | |||
| shall be reconsidered only in | shall be reconsidered only in | |||
| accordance with the processes in place at the time of the suspension, | accordance with the processes in place at the time of the suspension, | |||
| even if the corresponding RFC has been formally obsoleted.</t> | even if the corresponding RFC has been formally obsoleted.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="relationship-to-other-ietf-functions"> | <section anchor="relationship-to-other-ietf-functions"> | |||
| <name>Relationship to other IETF functions</name> | <name>Relationship to Other IETF Functions</name> | |||
| <section anchor="relation-to-the-ombudsteam"> | <section anchor="relation-to-the-ombudsteam"> | |||
| <name>Relation to the Ombudsteam</name> | <name>Relation to the Ombudsteam</name> | |||
| <t>Administrators and moderators shall complement the efforts of the IET | <!-- [rfced] What does "operation" refer to? [OT] does not mention | |||
| F | "operation". Perhaps this refers to "operating practices" or "operational | |||
| ombudsteam <xref target="OT"/>, whose focus on anti-harassment and operation | procedures" as used in RFC 7776? | |||
| Original: | ||||
| Administrators and moderators shall complement the efforts of the | ||||
| IETF ombudsteam [OT], whose focus on anti-harassment and operation | ||||
| shall remain unchanged. | ||||
| Perhaps A: | ||||
| Administrators and moderators shall complement the efforts of the | ||||
| IETF Ombudsteam [OT], whose focus on anti-harassment and operations | ||||
| remain unchanged. | ||||
| Perhaps B: | ||||
| Administrators and moderators shall complement the efforts of the | ||||
| IETF Ombudsteam [OT], whose focus on anti-harassment and operational processe | ||||
| s | ||||
| remain unchanged. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Administrators and moderators shall complement the efforts of the IETF | ||||
| Ombudsteam <xref target="OT"/>, whose focus on anti-harassment and operation | ||||
| shall remain unchanged. Administrators and moderators should always | shall remain unchanged. Administrators and moderators should always | |||
| report suspected harassment. They should nonetheless take any | report suspected harassment. They should nonetheless take any | |||
| necessary actions regarding disruptive behavior.</t> | necessary actions regarding disruptive behavior.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="relation-to-the-ietf-llc"> | <section anchor="relation-to-the-ietf-llc"> | |||
| <name>Relation to the IETF LLC</name> | <name>Relation to the IETF LLC</name> | |||
| <t>The Board of Directors of the IETF Administration LLC (IETF LLC) has | <t>The Board of Directors of the IETF Administration LLC (IETF LLC) has | |||
| fiduciary duty for the overall organization, which includes the duty | fiduciary duty for the overall organization, which includes the duty | |||
| to protect the organization from serious legal risk that may arise | to protect the organization from serious legal risk that may arise | |||
| from the behavior of IETF participants.</t> | from the behavior of IETF participants.</t> | |||
| <t>This protection may include the need for the IETF LLC to take | <t>This protection may include the need for the IETF LLC to take | |||
| emergency moderation actions. These emergency actions are expected to | emergency moderation actions. These emergency actions are expected to | |||
| be taken only when the IETF LLC has received legal advice that such | be taken only when the IETF LLC has received legal advice that such | |||
| action is necessary, and therefore extremely rare in frequency. Some | action is necessary and therefore will be extremely rare in frequency. Some | |||
| examples of where this might be necessary are:</t> | examples of where this might be necessary are:</t> | |||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <ul spacing="normal"> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Someone making a credible threat of harm to other IETF participan ts.</t> | <t>Someone making a credible threat of harm to other IETF participan ts.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Someone using IETF mailing lists and/or websites to share content | <t>Someone using IETF mailing lists and/or websites to share content | |||
| where publishing that content on IETF lists and/or websites brings | where publishing that content on IETF lists and/or websites brings | |||
| serious legal risk to the IETF.</t> | serious legal risk to the IETF.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Someone making a credible threat of legal action where any form o f | <t>Someone making a credible threat of legal action where any form o f | |||
| interaction with them on IETF mailing lists may have serious legal | interaction with them on IETF mailing lists may have serious legal | |||
| consequences for the IETF.</t> | consequences for the IETF.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <t>If any such action is taken, the IETF LLC should, except where | <t>If any such action is taken, the IETF LLC should, except where | |||
| limited by legal advice to the contrary, inform the IESG as soon as | limited by legal advice to the contrary, inform the IESG as soon as | |||
| possible, providing full details of the subject of the action, nature | possible, providing full details of the subject of the action, nature | |||
| of the action, reason for the action and expected duration. The IETF | of the action, reason for the action, and the expected duration. The IETF | |||
| LLC should also inform the moderator team and IETF community, except | LLC should also inform the moderator team and IETF community, except | |||
| where it receives legal advice to the contrary.</t> | where it receives legal advice to the contrary.</t> | |||
| <t>As such an action would be taken by the IETF LLC in order to protect | <t>As such an action would be taken by the IETF LLC in order to protect | |||
| the IETF according to its fiduciary duty, then it cannot allow that | the IETF according to its fiduciary duty, then it cannot allow that | |||
| to be overridden by a decision of the moderator team or the IESG. | to be overridden by a decision of the moderator team or the IESG. | |||
| The subject of any such action may request a review by the IETF LLC | The subject of any such action may request a review by the IETF LLC | |||
| board, as documented in <xref section="4.7" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC8711"/ >.</t> | Board, as documented in <xref section="4.7" sectionFormat="of" target="RFC8711"/ >.</t> | |||
| <t>Any such action taken by the IETF LLC under this section of this | <t>Any such action taken by the IETF LLC under this section of this | |||
| policy is not subject to the rest of this policy.</t> | policy is not subject to the rest of this policy.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="security-considerations"> | <section anchor="security-considerations"> | |||
| <name>Security Considerations</name> | <name>Security Considerations</name> | |||
| <t>The usual security considerations <xref target="RFC3552"/> do not apply to this | <t>The usual security considerations <xref target="RFC3552"/> do not apply to this | |||
| memo.</t> | memo.</t> | |||
| <t>There is the potential abuse of the moderation procedures by moderators , | <t>There is the potential abuse of the moderation procedures by moderators , | |||
| working group chairs, and potentially others that could lead to | working group chairs, and potentially others that could lead to | |||
| skipping to change at line 469 ¶ | skipping to change at line 622 ¶ | |||
| <t><xref target="genphil"/> explicitly states that viewpoints outside the rough | <t><xref target="genphil"/> explicitly states that viewpoints outside the rough | |||
| consensus are not in and of themselves disruptive.</t> | consensus are not in and of themselves disruptive.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><xref target="prod"/> provides transparency by requiring that moder ation actions | <t><xref target="prod"/> provides transparency by requiring that moder ation actions | |||
| that restrict participation privileges be immediately reported | that restrict participation privileges be immediately reported | |||
| to the affected person and to the moderation team, and | to the affected person and to the moderation team, and | |||
| periodically reported to the IESG.</t> | periodically reported to the IESG.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>That same section requires that the community be informed in the ca se | <t><xref target="prod"/> also requires that the community be informed in the case | |||
| of suspensions lasting longer than 14 days.</t> | of suspensions lasting longer than 14 days.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t><xref target="appeals"/> lays out an appeals process in the case of | <t><xref target="appeals"/> lays out an appeals process in the case of | |||
| disagreements.</t> | disagreements.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>If moderators find that the procedures themselves are leading to | <t>If moderators find that the procedures themselves are leading to | |||
| inappropriate moderation, <xref target="prod"/> allows them to update those proc edures | inappropriate moderation, <xref target="prod"/> allows them to update those proc edures | |||
| in consultation with the community, and with the approval of the IESG.</t> | in consultation with the community and with the approval of the IESG.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>If IETF participants believe that either the IESG or the IAB are no t performing | <t>If IETF participants believe that either the IESG or the IAB are no t performing | |||
| their respective oversight functions as described in this document, they may | their respective oversight functions as described in this document, they may | |||
| comment to the NomCom <xref target="BCP10"/> or the community at large.</t> | comment to the NomCom <xref target="BCP10"/> or the community at large.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Finally, if it appears that these processes are not functioning | <t>Finally, if it appears that these processes are not functioning | |||
| properly, the policies stated in this memo may be amended. | properly, the policies stated in this memo may be amended. | |||
| They are not set in stone.</t> | They are not set in stone.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ol> | </ol> | |||
| <t>Moderation actions are intended to limit the likelihood | <t>Moderation actions are intended to limit the likelihood | |||
| of disruptive behavior by a few IETF participants from discouraging | of disruptive behavior by a few IETF participants that may discourage | |||
| participation by other IETF participants.</t> | participation by other IETF participants.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="iana-considerations"> | <section anchor="iana-considerations"> | |||
| <name>IANA Considerations</name> | <name>IANA Considerations</name> | |||
| <t>No IANA actions are requested.</t> | <t>This document has no IANA actions.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="acknowledgments"> | <section anchor="acknowledgments"> | |||
| <name>Acknowledgments</name> | <name>Acknowledgments</name> | |||
| <t>This memo is based on two individual Internet-Drafts, | <t>This memo is based on two individual Internet-Drafts, | |||
| <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ecahc-moderation/">draft-ec ahc-moderation</eref> | <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ecahc-moderation/">draft-ec ahc-moderation</eref> | |||
| authored by Lars Eggert, Alissa Cooper, Jari Arkko, Russ Housley and Brian E. | authored by <contact fullname="Lars Eggert"/>, <contact fullname="Alissa Cooper" | |||
| Carpenter, and | />, <contact fullname="Jari Arkko"/>, <contact fullname="Russ Housley"/>, and <c | |||
| ontact fullname="Brian E. Carpenter"/>, and | ||||
| <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-lear-bcp83-replacement/">dr aft-lear-bcp83-replacement</eref> | <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-lear-bcp83-replacement/">dr aft-lear-bcp83-replacement</eref> | |||
| authored by Eliot Lear, Robert Wilton, Bron Gondwana and John R. Levine. | authored by <contact fullname="Eliot Lear"/>, <contact fullname="Robert Wilton"/ | |||
| Robert Sayre authored | >, <contact fullname="Bron Gondwana"/>, and <contact fullname="John R. Levine"/> | |||
| . | ||||
| <contact fullname="Robert Sayre"/> authored | ||||
| <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-sayre-modpod-excellent/">dr aft-sayre-modpod-excellent</eref>, | <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-sayre-modpod-excellent/">dr aft-sayre-modpod-excellent</eref>, | |||
| which also originated ideas reflected in this work. Pete Resnick provided the | which also originated ideas reflected in this work. <contact fullname="Pete Res nick"/> provided the | |||
| basis for how the moderators interact with list/forum leadership.</t> | basis for how the moderators interact with list/forum leadership.</t> | |||
| <t>These individuals contributed additional improvements:</t> | <t>These individuals contributed additional improvements:</t> | |||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | <ul spacing="normal"> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Alissa Cooper</t> | <t><contact fullname="Alissa Cooper"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Brian Carpenter</t> | <t><contact fullname="Brian Carpenter"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Chris Box</t> | <t><contact fullname="Chris Box"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Colin Perkins</t> | <t><contact fullname="Colin Perkins"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>David Schinazi</t> | <t><contact fullname="David Schinazi"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Eric Rescorla</t> | <t><contact fullname="Eric Rescorla"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Jay Daley</t> | <t><contact fullname="Jay Daley"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Joel Halpern</t> | <t><contact fullname="Joel Halpern"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>John Klensin</t> | <t><contact fullname="John Klensin"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>John Scudder</t> | <t><contact fullname="John Scudder"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Martin Thomson</t> | <t><contact fullname="Martin Thomson"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Melinda Shore</t> | <t><contact fullname="Melinda Shore"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Michael Richardson</t> | <t><contact fullname="Michael Richardson"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Nick Hilliard</t> | <t><contact fullname="Nick Hilliard"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Pete Resnick</t> | <t><contact fullname="Pete Resnick"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Rich Salz</t> | <t><contact fullname="Rich Salz"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Robert Sayre</t> | <t><contact fullname="Robert Sayre"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Russ Housley</t> | <t><contact fullname="Russ Housley"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Sean Turner</t> | <t><contact fullname="Sean Turner"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Simon Josefsson</t> | <t><contact fullname="Simon Josefsson"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Stephen Farrell</t> | <t><contact fullname="Stephen Farrell"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Ted Lemon</t> | <t><contact fullname="Ted Lemon"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Tim Bray</t> | <t><contact fullname="Tim Bray"/></t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <t>N.B., acknowledgment should not be taken as endorsement by the | <t>N.B., acknowledgment should not be taken as endorsement by the | |||
| individuals named above.</t> | individuals named above.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| </middle> | </middle> | |||
| <back> | <back> | |||
| <references anchor="sec-combined-references"> | <references anchor="sec-combined-references"> | |||
| <name>References</name> | <name>References</name> | |||
| <references anchor="sec-normative-references"> | <references anchor="sec-normative-references"> | |||
| <name>Normative References</name> | <name>Normative References</name> | |||
| <reference anchor="RFC2418"> | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.2 | |||
| <front> | 418.xml"/> | |||
| <title>IETF Working Group Guidelines and Procedures</title> | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.3 | |||
| <author fullname="S. Bradner" initials="S." surname="Bradner"/> | 935.xml"/> | |||
| <date month="September" year="1998"/> | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.7 | |||
| <abstract> | 154.xml"/> | |||
| <t>This document describes the guidelines and procedures for forma | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.8 | |||
| tion and operation of IETF working groups. This document specifies an Internet B | 711.xml"/> | |||
| est Current Practices for the Internet Community, and requests discussion and su | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.2 | |||
| ggestions for improvements.</t> | 026.xml"/> | |||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="25"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="2418"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC2418"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC3935"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>A Mission Statement for the IETF</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="H. Alvestrand" initials="H." surname="Alvestrand"/ | ||||
| > | ||||
| <date month="October" year="2004"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>This memo gives a mission statement for the IETF, tries to defi | ||||
| ne the terms used in the statement sufficiently to make the mission statement un | ||||
| derstandable and useful, argues why the IETF needs a mission statement, and trie | ||||
| s to capture some of the debate that led to this point. This document specifies | ||||
| an Internet Best Current Practices for the Internet Community, and requests disc | ||||
| ussion and suggestions for improvements.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="95"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="3935"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC3935"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC7154"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>IETF Guidelines for Conduct</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="S. Moonesamy" initials="S." role="editor" surname= | ||||
| "Moonesamy"/> | ||||
| <date month="March" year="2014"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>This document provides a set of guidelines for personal interac | ||||
| tion in the Internet Engineering Task Force. The guidelines recognize the divers | ||||
| ity of IETF participants, emphasize the value of mutual respect, and stress the | ||||
| broad applicability of our work.</t> | ||||
| <t>This document is an updated version of the guidelines for condu | ||||
| ct originally published in RFC 3184.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="54"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="7154"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC7154"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC8711"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>Structure of the IETF Administrative Support Activity, Versio | ||||
| n 2.0</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="B. Haberman" initials="B." surname="Haberman"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="J. Hall" initials="J." surname="Hall"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="J. Livingood" initials="J." surname="Livingood"/> | ||||
| <date month="February" year="2020"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>The IETF Administrative Support Activity (IASA) was originally | ||||
| established in 2005. In the years since then, the needs of the IETF evolved in w | ||||
| ays that required changes to its administrative structure. The purpose of this R | ||||
| FC is to document and describe the IETF Administrative Support Activity, version | ||||
| 2.0 (IASA 2.0). It defines the roles and responsibilities of the IETF Administr | ||||
| ation LLC Board (IETF LLC Board), the IETF Executive Director, and the Internet | ||||
| Society in the fiscal and administrative support of the IETF standards process. | ||||
| It also defines the membership and selection rules for the IETF LLC Board.</t> | ||||
| <t>This document obsoletes RFC 4071, RFC 4333, and RFC 7691.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="101"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="8711"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC8711"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC2026"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>The Internet Standards Process -- Revision 3</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="S. Bradner" initials="S." surname="Bradner"/> | ||||
| <date month="October" year="1996"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>This memo documents the process used by the Internet community | ||||
| for the standardization of protocols and procedures. It defines the stages in th | ||||
| e standardization process, the requirements for moving a document between stages | ||||
| and the types of documents used during this process. This document specifies an | ||||
| Internet Best Current Practices for the Internet Community, and requests discus | ||||
| sion and suggestions for improvements.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="9"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="2026"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC2026"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <referencegroup anchor="BCP10" target="https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/b cp10"> | <referencegroup anchor="BCP10" target="https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/b cp10"> | |||
| <reference anchor="RFC8713" target="https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rf | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC | |||
| c8713"> | .8713.xml"/> | |||
| <front> | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC | |||
| <title>IAB, IESG, IETF Trust, and IETF LLC Selection, Confirmation | .9389.xml"/> | |||
| , and Recall Process: Operation of the IETF Nominating and Recall Committees</ti | ||||
| tle> | ||||
| <author fullname="M. Kucherawy" initials="M." role="editor" surnam | ||||
| e="Kucherawy"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="R. Hinden" initials="R." role="editor" surname=" | ||||
| Hinden"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="J. Livingood" initials="J." role="editor" surnam | ||||
| e="Livingood"/> | ||||
| <date month="February" year="2020"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>The process by which the members of the IAB and IESG, some Tr | ||||
| ustees of the IETF Trust, and some Directors of the IETF Administration LLC (IET | ||||
| F LLC) are selected, confirmed, and recalled is specified in this document. This | ||||
| document is based on RFC 7437. Only those updates required to reflect the chang | ||||
| es introduced by IETF Administrative Support Activity (IASA) 2.0 have been inclu | ||||
| ded. Any other changes will be addressed in future documents.</t> | ||||
| <t>This document obsoletes RFC 7437 and RFC 8318.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="10"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="8713"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC8713"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC9389" target="https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rf | ||||
| c9389"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>Nominating Committee Eligibility</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="M. Duke" initials="M." surname="Duke"/> | ||||
| <date month="April" year="2023"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>The IETF Nominating Committee (NomCom) appoints candidates to | ||||
| several IETF leadership committees. RFC 8713 provides criteria for NomCom membe | ||||
| rship that attempt to ensure NomCom volunteers are members of the loosely define | ||||
| d IETF community, by requiring in-person attendance in three of the past five in | ||||
| -person meetings. In 2020 and 2021, the IETF had six consecutive fully online pl | ||||
| enary meetings that drove rapid advancement in remote meeting technologies and p | ||||
| rocedures, including an experiment that included remote attendance for NomCom el | ||||
| igibility. This document updates RFC 8713 by defining a new set of eligibility c | ||||
| riteria from first principles, with consideration to the increased salience of r | ||||
| emote attendance. This document obsoletes RFCs 8788 and 8989.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="10"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="9389"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC9389"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| </referencegroup> | </referencegroup> | |||
| <reference anchor="RFC7776"> | <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.7 | |||
| <front> | 776.xml"/> | |||
| <title>IETF Anti-Harassment Procedures</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="P. Resnick" initials="P." surname="Resnick"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="A. Farrel" initials="A." surname="Farrel"/> | ||||
| <date month="March" year="2016"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>IETF Participants must not engage in harassment while at IETF m | ||||
| eetings, virtual meetings, or social events or while participating in mailing li | ||||
| sts. This document lays out procedures for managing and enforcing this policy.</ | ||||
| t> | ||||
| <t>This document updates RFC 2418 by defining new working group gu | ||||
| idelines and procedures. This document updates RFC 7437 by allowing the Ombudste | ||||
| am to form a recall petition without further signatories.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="25"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="7776"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC7776"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| </references> | </references> | |||
| <references anchor="sec-informative-references"> | <references anchor="sec-informative-references"> | |||
| <name>Informative References</name> | <name>Informative References</name> | |||
| <reference anchor="IESG-SPAM" target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/s tatement-iesg-iesg-statement-on-spam-control-on-ietf-mailing-lists-20080414/"> | <reference anchor="IESG-SPAM" target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/s tatement-iesg-iesg-statement-on-spam-control-on-ietf-mailing-lists-20080414/"> | |||
| <front> | <front> | |||
| <title>IESG Statement on Spam Control on IETF Mailing Lists</title> | <title>IESG Statement on Spam Control on IETF Mailing Lists</title> | |||
| <author> | <author> | |||
| <organization>IESG</organization> | <organization>IESG</organization> | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <date year="2008" month="April" day="18"/> | <date year="2008" month="April" day="14"/> | |||
| </front> | </front> | |||
| </reference> | </reference> | |||
| <reference anchor="AHP" target="https://www.ietf.org/about/groups/iesg/s tatements/anti-harassment-policy/"> | <reference anchor="AHP" target="https://www.ietf.org/about/groups/iesg/s tatements/anti-harassment-policy/"> | |||
| <front> | <front> | |||
| <title>IETF Anti-Harassment Policy</title> | <title>IETF Anti-Harassment Policy</title> | |||
| <author> | <author> | |||
| <organization>IESG</organization> | <organization>IESG</organization> | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <date year="2013" month="November" day="03"/> | <date year="2013" month="November" day="03"/> | |||
| </front> | </front> | |||
| skipping to change at line 753 ¶ | skipping to change at line 800 ¶ | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <date year="2000" month="August" day="29"/> | <date year="2000" month="August" day="29"/> | |||
| </front> | </front> | |||
| </reference> | </reference> | |||
| <reference anchor="DP" target="https://www.ietf.org/about/groups/iesg/st atements/disruptive-posting/"> | <reference anchor="DP" target="https://www.ietf.org/about/groups/iesg/st atements/disruptive-posting/"> | |||
| <front> | <front> | |||
| <title>IESG Statement on Disruptive Posting</title> | <title>IESG Statement on Disruptive Posting</title> | |||
| <author> | <author> | |||
| <organization>IESG</organization> | <organization>IESG</organization> | |||
| </author> | </author> | |||
| <date year="2006" month="February" day="16"/> | <date year="2006" month="February" day="17"/> | |||
| </front> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC3683"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>A Practice for Revoking Posting Rights to IETF Mailing Lists< | ||||
| /title> | ||||
| <author fullname="M. Rose" initials="M." surname="Rose"/> | ||||
| <date month="March" year="2004"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>All self-governing bodies have ways of managing the scope of pa | ||||
| rticipant interaction. The IETF uses a consensus-driven process for developing c | ||||
| omputer-communications standards in an open fashion. An important part of this c | ||||
| onsensus-driven process is the pervasive use of mailing lists for discussion. No | ||||
| tably, in a small number of cases, a participant has engaged in a "denial-of-ser | ||||
| vice" attack to disrupt the consensus-driven process. Regrettably, as these bad | ||||
| faith attacks become more common, the IETF needs to establish a practice that re | ||||
| duces or eliminates these attacks. This memo recommends such a practice for use | ||||
| by the IETF. This document specifies an Internet Best Current Practices for the | ||||
| Internet Community, and requests discussion and suggestions for improvements.</t | ||||
| > | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="83"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="3683"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC3683"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC3934"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>Updates to RFC 2418 Regarding the Management of IETF Mailing | ||||
| Lists</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="M. Wasserman" initials="M." surname="Wasserman"/> | ||||
| <date month="October" year="2004"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>This document is an update to RFC 2418 that gives WG chairs exp | ||||
| licit responsibility for managing WG mailing lists. In particular, it gives WG c | ||||
| hairs the authority to temporarily suspend the mailing list posting privileges o | ||||
| f disruptive individuals. This document specifies an Internet Best Current Pract | ||||
| ices for the Internet Community, and requests discussion and suggestions for imp | ||||
| rovements.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="25"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="3934"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC3934"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC9245"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>IETF Discussion List Charter</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="L. Eggert" initials="L." surname="Eggert"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="S. Harris" initials="S." surname="Harris"/> | ||||
| <date month="June" year="2022"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>The Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) discussion mailing l | ||||
| ist furthers the development and specification of Internet technology through th | ||||
| e general discussion of technical, procedural, operational, and other topics for | ||||
| which no dedicated mailing lists exist. As this is the most general IETF mailin | ||||
| g list, considerable latitude in terms of topics is allowed, but there are posts | ||||
| and topics that are unsuitable for this mailing list. This document defines the | ||||
| charter for the IETF discussion list and explains its scope.</t> | ||||
| <t>This document obsoletes RFC 3005 and updates RFC 3683.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="45"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="9245"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC9245"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC7282"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>On Consensus and Humming in the IETF</title> | ||||
| <author fullname="P. Resnick" initials="P." surname="Resnick"/> | ||||
| <date month="June" year="2014"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>The IETF has had a long tradition of doing its technical work t | ||||
| hrough a consensus process, taking into account the different views among IETF p | ||||
| articipants and coming to (at least rough) consensus on technical matters. In pa | ||||
| rticular, the IETF is supposed not to be run by a "majority rule" philosophy. Th | ||||
| is is why we engage in rituals like "humming" instead of voting. However, more a | ||||
| nd more of our actions are now indistinguishable from voting, and quite often we | ||||
| are letting the majority win the day without consideration of minority concerns | ||||
| . This document explains some features of rough consensus, what is not rough con | ||||
| sensus, how we have gotten away from it, how we might think about it differently | ||||
| , and the things we can do in order to really achieve rough consensus.</t> | ||||
| <t>Note: This document is quite consciously being put forward as I | ||||
| nformational. It does not propose to change any IETF processes and is therefore | ||||
| not a BCP. It is simply a collection of principles, hopefully around which the I | ||||
| ETF can come to (at least rough) consensus.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | </front> | |||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="7282"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC7282"/> | ||||
| </reference> | ||||
| <reference anchor="RFC3552"> | ||||
| <front> | ||||
| <title>Guidelines for Writing RFC Text on Security Considerations</t | ||||
| itle> | ||||
| <author fullname="E. Rescorla" initials="E." surname="Rescorla"/> | ||||
| <author fullname="B. Korver" initials="B." surname="Korver"/> | ||||
| <date month="July" year="2003"/> | ||||
| <abstract> | ||||
| <t>All RFCs are required to have a Security Considerations section | ||||
| . Historically, such sections have been relatively weak. This document provides | ||||
| guidelines to RFC authors on how to write a good Security Considerations section | ||||
| . This document specifies an Internet Best Current Practices for the Internet Co | ||||
| mmunity, and requests discussion and suggestions for improvements.</t> | ||||
| </abstract> | ||||
| </front> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="BCP" value="72"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="RFC" value="3552"/> | ||||
| <seriesInfo name="DOI" value="10.17487/RFC3552"/> | ||||
| </reference> | </reference> | |||
| <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.3 | ||||
| 683.xml"/> | ||||
| <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.3 | ||||
| 934.xml"/> | ||||
| <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.9 | ||||
| 245.xml"/> | ||||
| <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.7 | ||||
| 282.xml"/> | ||||
| <xi:include href="https://bib.ietf.org/public/rfc/bibxml/reference.RFC.3 | ||||
| 552.xml"/> | ||||
| </references> | </references> | |||
| </references> | </references> | |||
| <?line 522?> | <?line 688?> | |||
| <section anchor="change-history-of-this-i-d"> | <section anchor="motivation"> | |||
| <name>Change History of this I-D</name> | ||||
| <aside> | ||||
| <t>RFC Editor: Please remove this appendix before publication.</t> | ||||
| </aside> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-11"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-11</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/238/">clarify when changes take effect</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/239">Refine security considerations</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/257/files">Multi group and moderator reversal</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/258">Last(?) bits from 2nd last call</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-10"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-10</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t>Many editorial suggestions received during WGLC.</t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/181">remove attendee mailing lists from moderator primary resp | ||||
| onsibility</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/149">Correct reference to appeals process.</eref> | ||||
| <eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-grou | ||||
| p-processes/pull/230">Also this.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/197">Clarify fora that are out of scope.</eref> | ||||
| <eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-grou | ||||
| p-processes/pull/181">Incl. attendees' lists.</eref> | ||||
| <eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-grou | ||||
| p-processes/pull/235">Also this.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/220">Clarify WG chairs are default admins but can delegate.</e | ||||
| ref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/231">Mod team size guidance.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/229">Chair immediately notify mods and affected parties.</eref | ||||
| ></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/232">Add all of the available mitigations to risks of censorsh | ||||
| ip.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/234">Clarify AD responsibilities.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-09"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-09</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/147">Try to find another happy medium on power of moderators</ | ||||
| eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-08"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-08</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/issues/142">Address timeliness and exisgent circumstances</eref></t | ||||
| > | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/143">Make clear that moderators should use their judgment on t | ||||
| iming</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-07"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-07</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/issues/134">Pete Resnick issues and similar</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/135">Includes changes to abstract, intro, tweaks to make relat | ||||
| ionship | ||||
| between admins/WG chairs clearer; makes roles clearer, | ||||
| moderation team → moderator team.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modmod-group-processes-06"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modmod-group-processes-06</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/129">Normalize handling of moderation across all fora</eref></ | ||||
| t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/132">Obsolete RFC 3934, explicit admin responsibility</eref></ | ||||
| t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-05"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-05</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/126">New attempt to address moderation/WG interactions</eref>< | ||||
| /t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-04"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-04</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/120">Use plain English instead of BCP 14 language</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-03"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-03</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/121">Non-normative Examples of Disruptive Behavior</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-02"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-02</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/105">Say which RFCs this obsoletes and updates.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/116">Address issue 113</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/103">Rewrite philosophy</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/107">Reinstatement</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/109">Content removal is not moderation.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-01"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-01</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/92">Update "Relation to the IETF LLC".</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/97">Point to relevant IRTF material.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/100">Add some text to explain the role of moderators.</eref></ | ||||
| t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-00"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes-00</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/80">Spelling fix</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/75">Initial attempt to balance what the moderator defines and | ||||
| what</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/76">Scope and relationship between WG chairs and moderators</e | ||||
| ref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/88">Fix wording, spelling and capitalization.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t><eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-gro | ||||
| up-processes/pull/87">Editorial changes to acknowledgments.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="since-draft-ecahc-moderation-01"> | ||||
| <name>Since draft-ecahc-moderation-01</name> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | ||||
| <t>Content taken from | ||||
| <eref target="https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-ecahc-moderation/01/">draft | ||||
| -ecahc-moderation-01</eref>. | ||||
| <eref target="https://github.com/larseggert/draft-ietf-modpod-group-processes/pu | ||||
| ll/65">Updated editors. Acknowledge authors of original pre-WG I-Ds.</eref></t> | ||||
| </li> | ||||
| </ul> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| <section anchor="motivation"> | ||||
| <name>Motivation</name> | <name>Motivation</name> | |||
| <t><xref target="introduction"/> summarized the process changes introduced by this memo. | <t><xref target="introduction"/> summarizes the process changes introduced by this memo. | |||
| This appendix discusses the background that led to them.</t> | This appendix discusses the background that led to them.</t> | |||
| <section anchor="background"> | <section anchor="background"> | |||
| <name>Background</name> | <name>Background</name> | |||
| <t>The IETF community has defined general guidelines for | <t>The IETF community has defined general guidelines for | |||
| personal interactions in the IETF <xref target="RFC7154"/>, and the IESG has | personal interactions in the IETF <xref target="RFC7154"/>. The IESG has | |||
| defined an anti-harassment policy for the IETF <xref target="AHP"/> for which th e IETF | defined an anti-harassment policy for the IETF <xref target="AHP"/> for which th e IETF | |||
| community has defined anti-harassment procedures <xref target="RFC7776"/>, | community has defined anti-harassment procedures <xref target="RFC7776"/>, | |||
| empowering an ombudsteam <xref target="OT"/> to take necessary action.</t> | empowering an Ombudsteam <xref target="OT"/> to take necessary action.</t> | |||
| <t>Dealing with <em>disruptive</em> behavior, however, is not part of th e role | <t>Dealing with <em>disruptive</em> behavior, however, is not part of th e role | |||
| of the ombudsteam. <xref target="RFC2418"/> tasks the chairs of each IETF workin g | of the Ombudsteam. <xref target="RFC2418"/> tasks the chairs of each IETF workin g | |||
| group with moderating their group's in-person meetings while | group with moderating their group's in-person meetings while | |||
| <xref target="RFC3934"/> provided chairs a procedure to help manage mailing | <xref target="RFC3934"/> provides chairs a procedure to help manage mailing | |||
| lists. An IESG statement <xref target="MODML"/> described additional guidance | lists. An IESG statement <xref target="MODML"/> describes additional guidance | |||
| to working group chairs about how — but not when — to moderate their | to working group chairs about how -- but not when -- to moderate their | |||
| lists.</t> | lists.</t> | |||
| <t>For IETF mailing lists not associated with a working group, another | <t>For IETF mailing lists not associated with a working group, another | |||
| IESG statement <xref target="DP"/> clarifies that the IESG tasks list administra tors | IESG statement <xref target="DP"/> clarifies that the IESG tasks list administra tors | |||
| with moderation. And the IETF list for general discussions | with moderation. And the IETF list for general discussions | |||
| has, mostly for historic reasons, a team of moderators that are not | has, mostly for historic reasons, a team of moderators that are not | |||
| list administrators and operate by a different set of processes | list administrators and operate by a different set of processes | |||
| <xref target="RFC9245"/>.</t> | <xref target="RFC9245"/>.</t> | |||
| <t>Note that the term "moderation" can refer both to <em>preemptive</em> | <!-- [rfced] May we update "with a spectrum from" as follows to improve | |||
| this sentence? | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| The IETF historically mainly | ||||
| practiced reactive moderation, with a spectrum from gentle reminders | ||||
| on- and off-list, all the way to suspension of posting rights and | ||||
| other ways of participating or communicating. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| Historically, the IETF has mainly | ||||
| practiced reactive moderation, employing actions ranging from gentle reminder | ||||
| s | ||||
| on- and off-list all the way to suspension of posting rights and | ||||
| other ways of participating or communicating. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <t>Note that the term "moderation" can refer both to <em>preemptive</em> | ||||
| moderation, where administrators review attempted participation before | moderation, where administrators review attempted participation before | |||
| it occurs | it occurs | |||
| (such as reviewing messages to a mailing list), and <em>reactive</em> moderation , | (such as reviewing messages to a mailing list), and <em>reactive</em> moderation , | |||
| where administrators intervene after disruptive participation has occurred. | where administrators intervene after disruptive participation has occurred. | |||
| The | Historically, the | |||
| IETF historically mainly practiced reactive moderation, with a spectrum from | IETF has mainly practiced reactive moderation, with a spectrum from | |||
| gentle reminders on- and off-list, all the way to suspension of posting rights | gentle reminders on- and off-list, all the way to suspension of posting rights | |||
| and other ways of participating or communicating. It is up to the moderators | and other ways of participating or communicating. It is up to the moderators | |||
| and administrators | and administrators | |||
| to decide which mix of preemptive and reactive moderation to employ as | to decide which mix of preemptive and reactive moderation to employ as | |||
| part of their procedures.</t> | part of their procedures.</t> | |||
| <t>In addition, <xref target="RFC3683"/> defines a process for revoking an | <t>In addition, <xref target="RFC3683"/> defines a process for revoking an | |||
| individual's posting rights to IETF mailing lists following a | individual's posting rights to IETF mailing lists following a | |||
| community last-call of a "posting rights" action (PR-action) proposed | community Last Call of a "posting rights" action (PR-action) proposed | |||
| by the IESG, often in response to complaints from the community.</t> | by the IESG, often in response to complaints from the community.</t> | |||
| <t>Experience and community input suggests that an evolution of the | <t>Experience and community input suggests that an evolution of the | |||
| existing processes is necessary.</t> | existing processes is necessary.</t> | |||
| </section> | </section> | |||
| <section anchor="motive"> | <section anchor="motive"> | |||
| <name>Problems with the Previous Approach</name> | <name>Problems with the Previous Approach</name> | |||
| <t>The previous approach to moderation of disruptive participation | <t>The previous approach to moderation of disruptive participation | |||
| through chairs, list administrators, and moderator teams, combined | through chairs, list administrators, and moderator teams, combined | |||
| with the IESG-led process of PR-actions, has proven to be less than | with the IESG-led process of PR-actions, has proven to be less than | |||
| ideal:</t> | ideal:</t> | |||
| skipping to change at line 1091 ¶ | skipping to change at line 902 ¶ | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>Chairs and list administrators may only enact moderation actions for | <t>Chairs and list administrators may only enact moderation actions for | |||
| their single list, which is ill-suited when a pattern of disruptive | their single list, which is ill-suited when a pattern of disruptive | |||
| behavior spans multiple lists. Also, chairs and list administrators | behavior spans multiple lists. Also, chairs and list administrators | |||
| may not be fully aware of disruptive behavior that spans multiple | may not be fully aware of disruptive behavior that spans multiple | |||
| lists, due to not being subscribed to some of them.</t> | lists, due to not being subscribed to some of them.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>PR-actions, which can address disruptive behavior across several | <t>PR-actions, which can address disruptive behavior across several | |||
| lists, are cumbersome and slow, and inconsistent. This has | lists, are cumbersome, slow, and inconsistent. This has | |||
| led to a situation where PR-actions are rarely used, and when they | led to a situation where PR-actions are rarely used, and when they | |||
| are used, they are perceived as very heavy-handed.</t> | are used, they are perceived as very heavy-handed.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>For a given mailing list, participants may not feel comfortable | <t>For a given mailing list, participants may not feel comfortable | |||
| reporting disruptive behavior to a chair or list administrator, for | reporting disruptive behavior to a chair or list administrator, for | |||
| various reasons. For mailing lists not associated with working | various reasons. For mailing lists not associated with working | |||
| groups, list administrators are not even publicly identified - they | groups, list administrators are not even publicly identified -- they | |||
| can only be contacted through an anonymous alias address. This | can only be contacted through an anonymous alias address. This | |||
| exacerbates the problem, because participants may not be | exacerbates the problem, because participants may not be | |||
| comfortable reporting disruptive behavior to an anonymous party.</t> | comfortable reporting disruptive behavior to an anonymous party.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | ||||
| <!-- [rfced] Please consider updating this text as follows to improve | ||||
| readability: | ||||
| - revising the first sentence (it is difficult to follow because a "not only" | ||||
| phrase is usually paired with "but also"). | ||||
| - adding "However" and "e.g." to the second sentence. | ||||
| - updating "How disruptive behavior is moderated" the third sentence as shown | ||||
| below. | ||||
| Original: | ||||
| * The IETF offers participation not only through in-person meetings | ||||
| and mailing lists, which are the two channels of participation for | ||||
| which moderation processes are currently defined. IETF business | ||||
| also happens in chat groups, remote meeting participation systems, | ||||
| virtual meetings, wikis, GitHub repositories, and more. How | ||||
| disruptive behavior is moderated in these fora is currently | ||||
| undefined. | ||||
| Perhaps: | ||||
| * Moderation processes have been defined for only two channels of | ||||
| participation in the IETF: in-person meetings and mailing lists. | ||||
| However, IETF business now happens in a number of fora (e.g., chat | ||||
| groups, remote meeting participation systems, virtual meetings, wikis, | ||||
| and GitHub repositories). Procedures for moderating disruptive behavior i | ||||
| n these | ||||
| fora are currently undefined. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| <ul spacing="normal"> | ||||
| <li> | <li> | |||
| <t>The IETF offers participation not only through in-person meetings | <t>The IETF offers participation not only through in-person meetings | |||
| and mailing lists, which are the two channels of participation for | and mailing lists, which are the two channels of participation for | |||
| which moderation processes are currently defined. IETF business | which moderation processes are currently defined. IETF business | |||
| also happens in chat groups, remote meeting participation | also happens in chat groups, remote meeting participation | |||
| systems, virtual meetings, wikis, GitHub repositories, and more. | systems, virtual meetings, wikis, GitHub repositories, and more. | |||
| How disruptive behavior is moderated in these fora is currently | How disruptive behavior is moderated in these fora is currently | |||
| undefined.</t> | undefined.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| skipping to change at line 1147 ¶ | skipping to change at line 987 ¶ | |||
| <t>"Sealioning", where a participant makes incessant requests for evid ence or | <t>"Sealioning", where a participant makes incessant requests for evid ence or | |||
| data, even while remaining superficially polite.</t> | data, even while remaining superficially polite.</t> | |||
| </li> | </li> | |||
| </ul> | </ul> | |||
| <t>These items are examples. Moderators and administrators may take modera tion | <t>These items are examples. Moderators and administrators may take modera tion | |||
| actions for many other cases.</t> | actions for many other cases.</t> | |||
| <t>The moderator team's task consists of | <t>The moderator team's task consists of | |||
| subjective judgment calls. Behaviors not listed here might require | subjective judgment calls. Behaviors not listed here might require | |||
| moderation, and it is not possible to write a complete list of all such | moderation, and it is not possible to write a complete list of all such | |||
| behaviors.</t> | behaviors.</t> | |||
| </section> | <!-- [rfced] Please review the "Inclusive Language" portion of the online | |||
| Style Guide <https://www.rfc-editor.org/styleguide/part2/#inclusive_language> | ||||
| and let us know if any changes are needed. Updates of this nature typically | ||||
| result in more precise language, which is helpful for readers. | ||||
| Note that our script did not flag any words in particular, but this should | ||||
| still be reviewed as a best practice. | ||||
| --> | ||||
| </section> | ||||
| </back> | </back> | |||
| <!-- ##markdown-source: | <!-- ##markdown-source: | |||
| H4sIAAAAAAAAA7V9W5MTSZLue/yKGHho4EgqCopL02uzU1ybWehmqWrjYWwf | H4sIANMynWkAA9V965ITV7bm//0Uu4sfBkYSVxuMT7RPATamDxiGqg7PhMMx | |||
| UsqQlEsqU5OXKtQYZvu0P+DY+YX7S45/7h6RESkVNLbV8zBNScoIDw+/33I6 | kVJuSXlIZarzUkImiDgPMvNy50lmfWutfcmUqsCGPjHT0dFNpTL3Ze11v+3p | |||
| nZqu6Er3xN54/eL8pX1WbzZ9VXQ7+7bOXZN1RV3dMIusc6u62T2x88XWmLxe | dGq6oivdI3vy/IfzH+2TerPpq6Lb25d17pqsK+rqxGTzeeMurn6n6jdz1zyy | |||
| VNmGnsmbbNlNC9ctp5s639b5dNXU/Xa6beqFa1vXTo8fmrafb4q2pYW63ZYe | 3357/2vTuqZwbVU/snfpr7xeVNmG5sibbNlNC9ctp5s639b5dNXU/Xa6beqF | |||
| wj6m6jdz1zwxOa38xCzqqnVV27dPbNf0zlw8sfdNPW/r0nWOPrz/8PH9ib3/ | a1vXTsusc21nFvR/q7rZP7Lzxda0/XxTtC1N0+23NAxWYRZ11bqq7dtHtmt6 | |||
| 4/0T02/xCH127+T48cT+eO/kgblwVU+rWPrfJivKJ5aAmeZFu+jb9m+AblY3 | Z4ptw/9qu7u3b397+66p521dOhrukb33zcN7E3vv23v3Tb/NM3529/6dhxP7 | |||
| K/56VXTrfv7EllnTutXKNd3RN8/AD5bYtHti1123bZ8cHQ0LzGTNWVF/e6lv | Lda3LR7ZX7t6MbHtftO4ZUv/qJsO//rN0LbvmTKrVo+sqww+pm9v3/1mSlNk | |||
| /2K27jalMVnfrWtCj5ny7oLtN7SnfcGb8qdNjXtzedHVDX9Ap3xC9/Z7UZYZ | jcse2Wc//Gx2dfOW9/LIys7MW7enh/kjY7K+W9fNIzM1lv4jkHiRNa39YbVy | |||
| f9B2jXME9VnnKkL3qqi6wtnje/Ypf72ge35i/y2jC8+KylXyId07UcPde4/u | TcdPmxpn4PKiqxt+UDc04cv696IsM37Q0npc98ieda4iQK+KqiucvXPXPuaf | |||
| 3r2hn/RVh8t/+Zr/doJkoOBvigOP374pnth/8Ugavjz6a3KSF2VRd/aNy5qv | F3Qej+y/ZXQwWVHRSvkhnQ+d2u27D27fPtEnfdUBrj8+57/dJivKR7ak5fyr | |||
| HOQZXWBtz3Zt5zZtcpz3xWLdFfRXRiizj2KwH9+/e3IjOtyHrCyL1pVlOJ2e | 4+XMaGb+qW8ILOuu27aPbt2Kv90a7OOHsqg7+8JlzRXbeFK0i9qe7dvObdrB | |||
| 5eyy6H53TZlVOX+xXdcVFvg/J8f25MQ+fvSYaMtjwJ+YAP4b/m+2WBtT1c2G | Zt4Ui3VX0F8Znb59kC764b3b90+Srf2SlWXRurIMe9OdnO2K7nfX0BHl/MN2 | |||
| +OOCKM8U1XL4yxKJn72anr07fStEqRyGT+kqiJI2rupsXdmzbbYhliOI6hJ/ | XVcY4L/dv2Pv37cPHzykU/b79/ulBf8r/me2WBtT1c2GsPjC0WEV1TL+ZQnV | |||
| Mwu+pb2KamXf0Anl3MwklqB5PL17Mj1+zB96ErHyv6kgDXvInlmzchHB0hoZ | zp5Nz16fvnzEnyut4CkdBOHCxlWdrSt7ts02RBi0orrE30woL2muolrZF7RD | |||
| IWzx0TUzzxJHxMhHrQeIyLJdyf8Nn9XVtCUgpwsBEn8L9QqQ0xJATgHa3ZPj | 2bdHn9sPp7fvT+/c54ceP6z8ZypAwxwyZ9asACt/FDRGRgBbvHXNDKTEh0Ik | |||
| kyPa+vTnd6NT05lOifCmP2e4MD77u7osFrvkcMf3p8fH07v3Dx3um6e7vLwc | dqv1CyIKa1fyP/FZXU1bWuR0IYvE30KIsshpiUVOsbTb9+/cv0VTn/70erRr | |||
| TpXN6747YsZqj3Ce4YztUQZI1gGS6ZYhAeC/nidw/7qZ9znRXraJwFxmZeu+ | 2tMpod30pwwHxnt/XZfFYj/Y3J170zt3prfvHdvcR3e32+3irrJ53Xe3mK7a | |||
| DQGwlS26ozqsgQ3e/vr87Zt9injVF3lWLRwIoFu7SPDaeino+1A3H0ESr3Cm | W9hP3GN7K8NK1mEl0y2vBAt/dT5Y96vNvM8J97JNssxlVrbu4ysAtLJFd6sO | |||
| rxHI3SnRyL0f/2Qcppe/CfDikM/Htz+m+edF2/RbcApRQdvROukRHk7v3oPa | Y2CCl6+evnxxiBHP+iLPqoUDAnRrl7BHWy8FfL8QnwBKPMOerkKQ21PCkbvf | |||
| +HOPkAcoiAIYiiMSttOpzeaQK4vOmHO6C8b+IujES5KspKFc1tmtq7elo0+6 | /pNhODz8TVgvNvl0fPpjnH9atE2/BaUQFrQdjTPcAljk9M6Df/IW8rAKwgBe | |||
| taW7ySsS35aEiV3R025i531nKxJyrspLfLUlDDm65RkWLlq7cZvaBhVn3798 | xS1jptOpzebgK4vOmH/5C/35a7NcuPw3++P/fE6zn6+L1hLR9LyZddbauXOV | |||
| 1rKa4zWg6Sb8r6KzqvHkJ9B6/AUrPlJJ2ZxuYQ1yyKzQsiVRxIS0SQhpOLHZ | JVwqVpXLbWYrt7OPn7y2ItfoF9O4f/QknFw+s/Y1MQ/iWFXdOTrqrLM7Z3fE | |||
| Zk1XLIotf2eyRVMTgJ0e94fWXmRNUfcEc0+LLyzzfkEHwkqLdVZVrpSzqo7F | q62XOvbNj09U7hBj4pEe3pNX5o6G6oqGprlOz1tLYgQjhW/zGzPawV+PLvwX | |||
| 57RpNjOv6cAeJgJ51WcNqbyibA2AigDC05n/APASj8ysPV8TavFvQXXuLlxZ | nSevGcWWdVnWO+DQbk3rp1UQxl4Qq5Zfi5KWVxtay/8AwpqpfZJtiy4ri9+d | |||
| b21mWtfhENEKrDLzvnECyjJbEFHignGSogHULdEnqK7Y0FXh3uVJ3JmhcxSN | /c//+N8kXR/953/8H1sIwkaAuIxQgVZBOHzh+LfTxduq3pUuXzHcbesWjNld | |||
| PJrlm6JidUKQtDMmg02R070Zc9O+huDL+wXjKrq7+Jx/GurrihjNfecNLECg | bbPtllgp7YtYp77Mx91+ZU/zvGHJbvT9YztTYBYk0GnhWbW3Kjxbe33u9jXB | |||
| gMqk+LVdHTA6wh598xUEmmy7JWgY5ivoF4t4Qm3rjaMNCtqW+ScYNxPb9psN | j4ZrFdI6W1EZzMTYeYPg0Ni+ZcpLUYgmmIo0YkRq6cPFemYPl0BgbXuScW1n | |||
| nfB3l9u1a4gZnpJGAouC1L0OpbPQBrlrF3Rmhy8In42jTzoiJfz5+fOmJnTy | WUMARHl4966jjRGMsdEFycliuZd1yM/E9nEeZk7norRN8mjNvy7WWUFiHuef | |||
| b798SUDaZB+dYHRZl2V9Cc4Axlb4lG7tU8HcPgAFI8v+Gg7y+fO/EqOBE798 | 5ZuiYkFHa2kxVrHZlkJK9KphDSjvCVYzDw7SuAq3mxnzqilI2mclU885T+2n | |||
| sZmsdENFhG2K1bprb9hb797fttlCQO0IsCXdEkRxRmA2bluSCMjtfDfsor+R | tbm7oMVtCV9b14HLRBrG23FYXsUyWxC9g3YwadEAWVpaFVYR1iMMizchG8BA | |||
| YxfVT4f2JKaXPWlJXaS1lyr6WY5FdEWbDXc4Xu7MCWz3QX1YG9ICa+Oq6UCt | h3ughb12zTojWH/2ugC5TwRb3ALG+cguFNnOaVDmvougufIiSQmhRW9dTd/I | |||
| o8vNSSY1GYmr7Zp+RusNz52kz008Ikb0FICk79jqocuOCBLqIeYE5nGC9Del | 9HR+eUX4ypOviHu4iZ33HVOnq/ISP21paEdcfoaBiYts3KYOpNuC7lsmfB4D | |||
| k2G/h7Nj7PgX2hECDjvO3SLrW3doW4gG2g6YoSslBUA4FUGcIktZnG5dF3Ax | OqdwgEIxy78C/ZN/gApq53trCPmyOXHiNZAosyLPGLMBlc1AmESuZ7ZZ0xWL | |||
| J1raYp1dEJXORNbHdxWRXhdIC5cLHJc7qwwxJw1Ay7NHA3K4KEjItyK5Ifzp | YivAzRZNTYvsdMtftfaCcLbuad09Db6wLP8L2hRGIlBXlStlvzTmomc1G5Nm | |||
| u5qhaxwciBzqK6uK3xkfzA6LNeHWsACoOtdUJObeu5ZMTPriPGs/2pd1Q6bB | M/OcNu3XRMte9VlDGnxRtgaLShbER+UfYL2EB7PLccIc4MRnIqq5FGVmLAo2 | |||
| rdfvz1/enqQ/PKUfFR2hkEjAPq1J1NLvTp/qzwiX9sw1BM/IfLj1/uzDq9sT | RU5nZ8w1+xzKT94zK0rPL93nPw30dUXC1v3BE1gASbEqM4QviMFDdAS9AZkc | |||
| O/rR6ZYQcJGVfqX3Z7yUCrTXVe62pMsgTvmh4NSRdid5s5nwDZDGVenhPgFD | ANAQA6XVKIEcxWEM4pG1rTeOJihoWqahYKuRkdRvNrTD30mQrV1DBPGYtFKI | |||
| RMlEYY6F7wxYphsN3Eicat1ySQewl2snxk8kl8ItGOZ4+iYnEqYrc3Rz9POM | aaC716NpLxC1rl3Qnh1+IHiSmMhdR6iEP9+/39QETn73w4fZceEg3NCejIDQ | |||
| ARY+Ewl69oqu8uZNe+4akuh1Wa929pe6IzH+lITepRyZkLexNxKZf4PuZ+mE | uG1JVBqhnsIQWo1JDg9fnPDmaJskLiwkmi2WLHL8fnd1X+bE8mlL5XbZl4wF | |||
| VBgI1e3r2uDOyVQsVlW6EVNVVmUrB+HPQr0nh8jL7VTMq8Sm2x/J65503iC6 | zPi7/ZgZ3yRdMwDtTAXiPSDJr0TjIOzf5EBocST/IMgIZTJiLNs1vaXakP/w | |||
| +lYll4DI398wtBFDhx2zaud3EMkab+MVQyArKFg1FcGKE8DRCW9MRrAQhjMS | /uBD4hptin2X7lhHGe3bjvY9Ytf/JSvn8xgtP3fLohI06FIdTEf86HmOuYzn | |||
| +OQ3zuuG3RjajnwSv9Krovu5n9NDhv71JpvPQJd0xxk068TznUn4jlGXqFbw | 8B6JN9lb/TqqRqCxlWPx4d4VrCNGNGatKMLi/fvvaR/g3x8++H2cqGJp6ezX | |||
| eAYLCjiWY0Bp0d+ZJ5uEg1tDKKHV1+Tv2W63JY4rifmKalH2RB3J6UQFDSds | XXtir79+c8Nmsnfi67InyElahe4gB0sPk4Rtg06K6rtjU5KkkClpxAAGr1Ow | |||
| xQTbQGIbstpr/9iBY7b757T+nKeVcLCe1eAI6aFwTtYS9WVFRHQDp6zIT/rw | 8jsUopHox8MNzvN7PRaMfeWBxu/uD7/7FExkU/ny04pYOLV/V0KL830zu4MZ | |||
| Si4pgVII9JWjXxKrvVsXZd3W2/XOfr65ctWW/v6i2kwsCjIJFnWDdTvyT6EX | /0IzQipixrlbZH3rjk3L6pYVnaGryWogmIr0HgJLZQIdug7gUtZtaYp1dkFs | |||
| GVlkcJKwyfusbFXntFuoawgkQqlZ9g2gxrYAbVXjhwSXtzSYOqpEHBGL/UW0 | bSYKQnpWCa/qAmZBSweMy71VDjpn7VqIENhwUZBm0Iq4h8ZAv9W8usbBr5XD | |||
| EEl8wwSxAT0llhRLWb4+sXfKrCCh1neilPH8o+MHJ6ySyc4PrK+mygUdA48W | 5smq4neGB/PPxRqGBeN61bmmIrb0xomWas+z9q39sW7Inrz+/M35jzcmwxdP | |||
| ZIEDmovCXfKS2I1ImyyqKifh0yaAMQ8S8c8dhApJC5eLhMXnZM5UpFOzslvv | 6aWiIxASCtjHNclmeu/0sb4G8+OMvXAjm/P6m7Nfnt2Y2NFLp1sCwEVW+pHe | |||
| ZoPJXsjxSGJdsaicJIt4YDrPWuJxop3VeghIea1AO/KlBqdfxdPW23hCpLQv | nPFQKgGfV7nbkgIE+csfBY8cmYQkoDYTPgEy01TcuHeAEGEyYZhjaT0DlFsX | |||
| YwK689G9x/eAiRfVisQEwYxLIvCXfRmzntxn6/HA6nlBkDOzaEiARYFpSbyW | iZEI1brlkjYgtkvnD0EEWTgFwyKCfskJhenInJpqvGChM2EWZ8/oKK9ds+eu | |||
| rMBJIMAggoqZO7kfUnAuj/TbBPEJq4/AIgP5XPVjr9Yipbtj9NLV4tesUBgz | IRWgLuvV3v5MBpoxz0fMZqLKe7OxJwN94YSOaukEa3g9qhuua/j6onmYzMkI | |||
| NmBmZn6uLwn9zUSkt9+DTVoVZDBeiZRgdw57ebU7EUNRzahN3/JhoBVYHtVN | llXZykFxYIWgJ2nhZf5QRVBpT4gwkvU96UuRifWt8jBZIv9+YmgiXh2bXCSx | |||
| LkKP+Ics96IyOVkthAdPx8EtU/0d+wZCnUL2IsLVHBRzj3QdnXag6wlZv0Uj | dAaRyuk0XqkIGAblTF0NoMoJ1tEJmUxGayFgZ6QslCUZ3Q27wWi6ugwjPSu6 | |||
| VNUVG6AiteB1r4U6L2K2Q5SJGCNjQi31q8WyCKj0K0g/WDKqORu3guqFoB9+ | n/o5fWToXy+y+QwoSsedQSubeBI0AxJk0A01eSL3DBo4YCzbgMITDCvCoAEx | |||
| WHUkAxAhs0odvAXd7bZxF+wrkAmwBmwwimJPgc1COqoLWLggUeSNlizPGzim | t4ZAQqOvC1pFt98S8ZVEh0W1KHtClMHuRH2JO2xFhd+Ad5usbGv/2ZFttof7 | |||
| ecSn9DM4zYmjtghLPc1KjlOQ4Ktago/cWaKSFV0Nro7EJIz+i4w+JIzFEqqo | tLpPZhIn9a4i9DjB+qu6mv7yTIXccH7stxLSV8jwhsf2E+HqM0fjEdW9Xhdl | |||
| LuoSmpodNRFNBKunCTBBnV4pQ477ikGh+y/AMq1Kg8YNxPwT1qaH3pFJQJ/w | 3dbb9d6+v7Zy1Zb+/qBybVE3mLSrKx6GMVk11KIVkJHZQtwn77NSZicC2kLh | |||
| avOmzohLyVen22LRSEZY0UEH4Py4PVH0eQ1BOewEyiT4vFraidHBPkVJDsQc | A4ciwJpl32A13qpd1XiRx1IpCxypBvyJaO4vIpZIBBhGiw2waqCLB5tN11Nm | |||
| ftIuxmEme9kGls3o9PAKoJmKZtFvIIxInBDF/ntPkPFhBOWx9Qk3B+YGjBbP | BXG5vhO1Dt8/uPP1fVbqnhZt4AWq7F7QrvBpAX8CrYY1PAyJ2QjBSSev8gxu | |||
| wnRewvolM263Fl5kFiNmNMIRxLhZsWmVHUD8kCveECOavnOHJMadO0S0pL7W | gHRhTIlEAqSiEZch9gF3DRR/ekz6cAXnRdmt97No9xWyO+Jgl4wpG8kSQpjO | |||
| GyZ8KMmIybzYJKZ2JV0HIQaSpJqu4QIRrlx1UTR1xVKdfi5iD7jcZLuIujma | SevMLSHQah1jDV5KTOAgopeC51jZ1dYbCYKpNC8DArL0wd2HdwGIH6oV8Yp8 | |||
| RWu5fxIOiM7rjlcSCueAiMBMKv8gbWdtN9B1StUz9so5Uhr8gnOE6SIvUD0y | wmdEq4eKmdCfHGfrwcDiekErZwRSvzLzA9OuWVPFuYrjBSJn7uR4SOC5PJF3 | |||
| NmqC8mKDMYMpETwCVZDmq943O9b2dOyGeF+frf80XEH3HRC66okeS4bmQAyE | Ezi5rX4ClR7IdNnLXswlQnjP4KWTxdssYBgyNkBmZn6qdwT+ZiLc3M/BNpFy | |||
| nxtcb/Ot2AXrvcEbh2BL6WVsZYPvCRKY7nlMsoCcDHiiQlvAqi+WhVjaYoWr | M1g/hEkwXOJcXgxPvEK16VveBwQE86O6yYXpEZWR1VdUJicFhkDgMTiY9SrK | |||
| aAG0pXe3XeRBEqdXdNHlvrfEAj9ETMTeeVZviAcLH0JRE5rOIaYAFiVmJipq | U7tS8FIQXli4KoZQ/MYuILEBciGxeV/CTCARu2EbAOoSPSES30S8b+AxkmUY | |||
| ByS3s1iqe6ST4dUVbAUqjloxt+zSXUJd0KntElom4sCDC4FciTWwdd0IgSHq | VniuFzM3m1iX0fETrjVd63GLYDO/MSNpjCPY1z2B4y0jshKnzq6ix6g7ymtS | |||
| J0ZAzUwg10TkB7Oj0ejda9J0roTfCpHhkMVqJ4NbIBFCeDZQe+QUcsLBrlzN | tCoyq+itE1XjT8Qt9X00Sez1tm/Y+mI6h+cKIpIOLBcjhuxOenhD/TV/AE5i | |||
| jjZH00hnkkEwCdaMBE+q4c95i73EjzQMrdhOouueRp6x4JEeJ79Pr5o/z1Tq | MJCKQEgRqX9CVmbRiLrTFRtgzNBS1nNZBLcPHEliJIP5D63iy8UYM3T9fPgC | |||
| wxSvYrrT45tBlt5qnaMb1ie+fLkdnYaVMqwMvaokpETuEeRL65oL4KKuhucQ | ywyveDRuBc0FwjG+VnVkhiMqpS5OHYYnw5nCrISFTnrUGistB9Y5adZx7y6A | |||
| +Tl9OoPXGJTA8DsjFvW8zgsJyqiBT0//Um+IVgbKCAj2BnpguPMGsCkLvnnz | 5oK4vVf+MnFwAqMDe6PX4LEe+bx4835UUYJzb4v9QCSEkb/wLCOLz89ShYkI | |||
| TNxWjlSQ5CrxX3xKAne5FAGsVwyTvV0TCYlXwFYlOwakmhrae3SecYjy9TKO | jsylvsBkbIdNPxNJDtGDpvk0BDmCGrAS/ghyXIEWxo4RY/qFDi2BoH2clRw/ | |||
| WxoYmsRFGw7AwoQFnJBoE9EcvBNB4bakZS4r2WJ/XdPWYOYleX7MMTdZotnn | IhWhammZriKazFbE8sASSaGAI+Yio4cEuFTmF9VFXV6oIFR+Ymxgs+KmH7BK | |||
| /trJnO6d15Krsp4TVVYZO/6RVS83pzhbF1v5Dj4DbyGKhGxHkC/bvro6/47M | THcK+k6XQny1gBRqVb42LsqH75gKp/a1sBQebd7UWQ4OSAayKBtk5xQddCvs | |||
| Hvt7XWksT64oMkLgPAJ9xAikCBbqh5Su43CVcIt352ldxEgkrMd6vawXH4Wa | H4coCnRegyXFmRBgNzaoe3vR69lqL8lEn8N3tU9hmMlctoHxMNq9Eff0omhI | |||
| RXVpnMDukEyzr3MHlp6kiGlj1SdGixE/hwWZCi/vPkAAWPp9w/ov4Rn2BtgD | u4d8Jwk99iJBSSU7Jc9k6AkiJd7hP3QWCBeOIZ7jbvj/3gtv9ueZWo/wa8FG | |||
| JCnUkAZmjQcjFjZRtYuPiZCmEIA5YLLaBYkXFZe7NH6Ny146B121WWIXgtho | 4KiBitw5yK7dsaDt1qJViP/aliQ/VYTQdFmxGbvWx3N1I2v1Y/N5YSXxTmHx | |||
| HohW08BEQ+yItRNPBVZP0XUin7dswAg55Ue08pKQyGpKn2X/buyCQuEMeCPa | 8MIRCNV98rkz6I7Cdsx4O2NBC8TaED3kkJEh2AL5LuqgXZLd0LHjod4Scjkm | |||
| rxysiazZIcAQySZTuRXJctwVTt6Qfi5gUvhdasSqWkLjQnGr+bthP8hwcJY4 | 3R2hiylYPSJdBzj0ucd4rsowhvQmK3GomzT8TWJApK2vxV6EBZFoIF6dnGCQ | |||
| OY8fHR+zu3fTnrHXAlDee28UWo14PPFoRX0J4w8WdGI/Q+FOvEVJykwcSHJq | nStpNzTphHXCNZxFhPOuuiiaumJ9l74QjRA0scn2CbPimFXG7NT9g9CZ9lB3 | |||
| QfATdeRhT4QsS1kQBhmBk9TfniQhAZOGzNlZE0pvJc0cbL5giXx41Yr5tyAL | PJjwLI45CDzJKjrKrTLsPuFUQ1Z1EKihGef/DtcLkVzR/v+6re+sYMLBsdFW | |||
| CEGq2jhSyfVuMg4aNI51XN1wCPCy+Fi0HGZhQrWae23ZMyYuaXAqtT95/Tx8 | 4KnIxe6Nh5gEgwb7TwfgET7x5L8MfL4McEYHbi1CHZyCEnxn58h/SByl6rRk | |||
| GpkIzQiT7L3cufNuINiW7Dnlk6y8zHatEKuzsQevR2YVbT5/9pGGL5xxUVeP | az/Yc+xUgeoavWZKnObKkAZHK+zp2FXnAyjsIRvGgIj0A0hXPQmUkldzJLDE | |||
| OYT0Dt093FXLcSfwyyHfjZijUWXF6NrgoN4DJF9HLOwqDZV4UaV+MIKw7NjS | 3yVhv48FhNgWjCEOoMGQg409URDcAWkSmYOVF21LvNEW8HwVy0K8UcIeVUXA | |||
| gehe6Bwp+8/krKcJqdOvACyZH8gjlLtx5EOCcmrWkSXF8aWiYkXcSJqVqTqJ | aqF6O+cDGe7DhxvB10oCu6IDLw/9imwKhWCUuAOe1BvidoWPTqmHiXYjNjIG | |||
| M7LVNsT3Yk4Sc8vHGU2IM9pTCRolYt7bVoK3Nk39DLjjm1E3c5mRoIbHgV1I | JdZJ2NRGULez1OjxoC9IyBfsJFFIteKzsEu3gzVFeycmCwqIgvToQEBbIhFM | |||
| Iw9+iMbLwlqNd8XERZ6ZFDFs0GRkKObKw4sCsC800hx4huCtW+9m04lUW/i7 | rTYEJ1WIeVwzMchhERrDHm80OPqcbEBXgswg+R2SKNpJ9JpJABY+QBiEJltw | |||
| GYXrcTVQSnI56gjB8upLXL6GgzRnRxdmOS6YpWG8SRwRJByTcZ7R82KopLk3 | PpdduZpd0hyoJIuJTOXJ0Mzvq/jnvMVc4nE1El5gp4KYggOhcyZS6+TFiyfi | |||
| pUc6C1koJTkLnI0q2pQRdt7MaenA9sIVbAfH6QROYIRsgpn36sixQaN8QiTh | 4pRAEP9NMmi5FB1Ct1c3bF9Fg7A2kvs4/jw8vGQMNQe9x4nfP7nx/UgMPU9U | |||
| tuQBEV9W9SUZ0GSTsYD46EhbM7+q678tMx+yOnCfM/OSqXgkk5UpSTEirRUj | udY1FwAZQKtqHKl+eSHxC/WAERR/rjeELRE3Aoi9Byuwi3MkRWIYpcawB5av | |||
| lu+fQGDMmXp+UXA6BAeqHGTxnrnmPWgJozNbBN/Hs8SYEZLccETusEqVTiOY | xMZK/P+lmyCBD/bFnrM5qxDuHe+GNM2GVpAs+NBbPxI+/7UbHZ7YYLdXn9tn | |||
| sHEbBza+LYgT4RG0xiBBgzNvoDX7dhx12MfjIXu/TQ6mFpCwYNBs4n1J2pMD | bpnlzOMkgiFUTHM8P32s7Iafe9MBftIq5X06lIkKuTIY/YI4TEJL7DGB90dh | |||
| 2w4Be9ZxEjob5Tej6Bs73yZ2/cUZQcAdbhNtDkJnC8FpgoDOJ7F70PtwD8yB | NIgV79Y1pNxoyfwdQrqnj2eXnIoRB+ZnHYnhI/mTiDeRYzB6DH/oDOzzZZqR | |||
| bPp7RuW42Igs8poV1mDIGM/hB8SCnBFijNin86EypayVBJE5bIcsQUYmxGbL | YDLi4xuObO9lkRCqE7E95LBJlmzJTtlVMvzhmKatIU2WHRKjiFlfY5Fqn3qO | |||
| to3aHZrdvijUW2iIpS5g5Iwz3uciw3hZUsRyDLMfBTp4okwjkf6eLhyrPfzU | Y8zT3ntv7Kqs58QQq4yjM4mnVY5NAbYutsGjK1MIl2rcEpyTHZI6Or9H9rP9 | |||
| eJWg1004IsaH2yiCWSmF2RgnnyX4FIDMcM4VyOXDq5DYo0frLZAn1RmES03J | va40Qi/nk1izcOsDdsSDSRdZqG+4dB3HFIVR+5gLjYtAlgTr2TIs68VbYaSi | |||
| XOKOcB1z0atIznTBC4D5Buc2d3NmvCHyWjSSwoAg+jDEY+cwZNtgTQffdwLT | zXtDYI80Wfs8d5AmkyFg2tQaELPXiO+ZJalKT+/Sheyx9H5zYBKceV8mYypk | |||
| lz4o3bLj3QPsP9j/7PMVB0k46d5xRsqFPJeXRItuEmLqhjZBnD9Tew9n4Agp | 8QJAqsR05dyvIFtw6Ekgz/sP7XVQwL/3bAngg3ruUaTobnxPxm5bTzS6H1K8 | |||
| GRW9ZAz5TGqzgUYC0hFSiilR/Ta2UvdTMGT4BV0CWHDbMxP5gMFgECSTU52z | TuD7oB8M6RB1Q6Yj63qODfsT/PNEAgYbjjV5L+ZbUlbWdU0y4DqcqsWGbP7m | |||
| SSUCcAgXjjngQMpnqVUAhvBVkT2qMmXRN7B1QjbHZyrGOWTcWUkHnSI6YIZE | hn/LDHYxZvXnAylldX57ZH6J8cTTjRsy1h7zoNoFyXTVVPbDfByg+dI5eLc2 | |||
| D5vtuiJbeAQrm3SzkUWzD47BsyoW8GRe0zFBwGwJXoJZWM2NzRc+7OsoMN0S | S0xEZ+U16oxF9NhKGC7zKihoVt5oselxKUuOB/LlFy+q/ZeA7RdY2wCq4BMN | |||
| TBoW7KuFSA/yJUmp8KnjA0ucxuczSeiASTYp4rhayMcA2DhWNaX+1KauuEAS | sXeMPYhIwAIuOtEu1FHLiV9VfotGXno3rn7LYZxREI2V6EiKxEsrB5s9a/Yz | |||
| 0jmJR4NaCS7lE7VIWCRqUDEYEfA+TeTtBBuLRCc5mzDpBoUSwwLpXorqX5K1 | e55qWqZyK1JNQf7YOTJZOf/Uz8LekZYoc6HkqsnecT5opODUEsx4+ODOHY7q | |||
| 3rXJgbiogTUDJz8CGUUiWuEh75G8fknjkSgqey038WoSBhrrYNFHQ8VP3Wha | XLNnHJ3AUt74oBM0dZIZam2oa5lVchEklzh/YURMvJvLtRonMssePNTrUGwl | |||
| nc0cH40IcaPU+zGMgZyIVIw3Yljah6A5xdm9D551k2DPqQFHcr/hgIn30vNs | +ZS8kkhPADgZhuAmg/ifGeZWsfdDmGcrNQkxodPbV788a8UntQAvgfvMODIz | |||
| N+3qKf1nCAgZAQOCRmraEsspBArOU0sSJo0aTkMWTTADmYDzuly8xFPlTS6G | 6v1kHCFsHGvsdcOh/13xtmg5psq8z2qifssBMGK8DXalTjEePw9PE7OnGUGS | |||
| oquxv/a8CztYZuDzwMScqYHY3kLMsCfpg5PbviGvxDEq2UkaebYpIbE/NHLE | c1Ru3nwdEbYlK1VZb1busn0ryBo0Cw3V6abZ5DDv3/vA4gdOztOgDtMIESqd | |||
| gDZCjbhJ8Y5zt6vZo48SVqFYYmZfSMJUJE6QNnQizSvhc3lOE7MTNtM8J8Qe | PgJTlsPMoJhjZErk0ajyzQDbYKs+1uPKVhx/1TDW6eWfRrzAtTmERVuik6Gd | |||
| 3fOhdtX6iFpDmxAB/QTS7Jpi4TM1RTUlLLTEi+aiIM0AhiBcrHfzpsjJ2nVS | DGXKTHZ7OkB2eguLJXMKKWflfhzilBi8GqtkH3JooKjYsGgkK5/xepBhwLZo | |||
| /ROnYX7yWsEvKhZ0LlD/FHvXvElj2JNVgcg5D7E7ECePKwY9e5oP66I8WMoS | DOentCRGpM8wMCHDwJ5KjHigO3iLUeDWDrMEI+xYBqoTfJmR9IcjFLOQjhfd | |||
| ZE+oUMEacYpfvVmj3uy+zcx4hCcqwhG2FrmqtTe36q1qESFTE1uC3lIbAyUO | oxoeD2M13kMsEbGZGQKGDbSMfWlCxcRxc/9JQjUqFSWqRjtSFcSfzShRB0cD | |||
| keaqf6taPi0u42lffrRvEVhYwauPv5rjq41+xbd4ONMIZA5xHdYsEjnOzFfS | TUcOR/2zsCT7sosuRU3vnCFKAg9rNozaT9IEAIJx7pYZfS+q7zAYrvhIeyGd | |||
| zcKjcRkpI+dQ/bRJymM/fw612KgqgjvesecGuSgex+nXYikmGHUtESQqPDwt | t3QrSVzkdKqEFPYevVvasL1wBVv3aSIRpy7FPCIz79XBzDqykgrhhNvCuxhS | |||
| h9ABy/dbbraaTaL6gddVy5EmwRbBc3tmzjhgoM97NV6xUVxoqFkktQaM4lLg | 2p3wiLeOdEAmWY1MbMvMB6ePHOjM/MhoPGLLSpck/5ACmUKWEYCWwKAz9fyi | |||
| d2nB3nmcg/t8k4tjjLnCZtF0PQxY1FFKCdrk0NWLGFQCMEkeY1QxSJIfscBM | 4Ewo7KhyGqU7sOPZsy8OLKaL4NLxNDGmhEEecYLvMLMVUZM1YeI2jbt8nBcP | |||
| SptYfdc2tqODXjf7+/xAgF2GGHvin3D2CtR71X4CIgy74LczmQxVukW17Um2 | uEcQHJGJhiCDgeDs23E05BCOxxwY7WBjqlcLDQbhJk4lSZHlRBaHBB0WcxIl | |||
| z93BEiGtTCRoV5z24/S0xC3F/aPnNlnuK1SIQEKem9UKu2iaec/rRQ+CDLkP | H+XCJoF29nSbka9J8mvgDGq40kN0BKf5QLQ9SdUBvsdjYApkV4YnVI6Aj7Ai | |||
| ro1quaCKlV/RmgAvGwpsx3co7BqVig41sL+ReVqa7qtIYP0cClAR9mZtr1mb | r1lkRe3YeAo/whZki2Bj8IP7yLgi1kpyRjhAj6SgjJSIzZa1G9U8NBH6olD7 | |||
| oXWFHRkkE3KpS4hTM2Tmea2HS8YPBA2aQCxEJsZSnetPfIxSTnRZpCnWJdmG | syGSuoCaM05BORcexsOSKJZtDIByxY582Yo/pgs+ArxpvETQwyYQEd3DCyZ8 | |||
| eY0kvVF3pdszwlIWGyxgNTk0/ADnmBFEj26INTzjhNCm2BS+ZoDxDZwhLwH8 | WfGEqRgbnw3AKesxcZsrDP3Ls5DRBw/uFrCTXH4CpSZgIUDApzEXwYpUrC6Y | |||
| +BAVfKO2q7dBCnGttBiAbCiTS8bB4Y3LYSeUO/LoJUkdpajF9i5dJsWy+v2i | lWxO9OD7c8n0DSkWRSMJS+BDv8TEizmMozbm3HhX3kRdz6Vbdjx7WPtXZIBI | |||
| bhoJZXnwCHlXar6FF3u+yIH1nlQk9F294RJB1gJeVRPWkcgr2g1n4N87LpkZ | gYykZ3eciuZCgpvnQ4tuEsIyhuP6nJcibJr2wEnXpFX0kirIe1KlDSgSYI5A | |||
| olLQVRD/vhivPfIimDPosXJSpUJXUfvsL35z7hAUBzYhGytOnBKR0Zrt1lWt | V4qI6ghgNfUw4Yo0vyBKsBYc9swkToWgLwiQ17Qk1qmE/cUg5pgAjiR4LTVf | |||
| atW0bAGrkkJbcckrmwy8AxfpShWyJiGDYaLVU1FppJb8kIlrEFqQUpoLMtK+ | 3BC8KlJIlaMs+gbKTsjd8qGfcfIozuwFNvoEHoCY1sV6u47IKh6tlXW62Uih | |||
| Ko55RZCYuFULUCFZZJL8RoQxtlIIjNPBNIzdWL4NbziMivWGww2iJqINldBi | OVyOwbfKFPBlXrtWyq6gCu5AKyzlxtoLb/Z5kobSLrJSg5V9tZBwpnsHkSJ5 | |||
| FguTagmEIcLb+I+iUJ0XLmJHH/TARfBocGM/zaxZ4YZvXx0cjThqCisxrCMI | IsmGxfnsExmJ5VwQ8myGgOPaEu/SZO1YhZTa6Ju64nJa8OZBsBzYSutSOlGF | |||
| h4ClMb9WaVmLh1FuOt8zi6JrZmFV1tVKU6xmWRMDoAjz1vHJbVjJbSjgSfHj | hBmixu6CDgGPhknMnaBiEeO0otFFcZKuBby9FMm/JHW9awcb4mxmlguc5RTQ | |||
| hgCMZPkkaO5398kArjNVkkBJF8JyncYs/olKCa/IFFjHgbUW+eXXyyvWFIXE | KGHQuh4yBetck/aIE5W9FiZ4IQn9jCWwSKNYG8JuIAkW7KN7K7jBh+aPYQjk | |||
| xXmZ0CiDwk77YIEMptqAsFiVREF0JrdxuWnk/e67OF5QArbVqpF4pkbVxyUv | hKSiuxHBSgzwFHv3fp2smwR1TvU3YvsNe+C85yfP9tOuntL/Rf+2kWWA0UgF | |||
| lvsBogiv5XiAhhw4deKT6WofIZdCZPNMfTKkXepSegQ+3/ROmBnHiUcMpXS0 | 5EBxCo6n86EiCY1G9aaYNSSQAU/Afl0uZuKp0iaXzdDR2Fc9z8IWlol0HoiY | |||
| 6OKzmn0bLBRBa0ovKms4WIjLLukigxIaRQ0sEuBD8iyu7IF42OGmgtXFDIHI | U7LAtbdgM2xK+ojLtm8QNmVQspU0Mm2HiMQG0cgSA9hQz8h2UjqjVOQxCENm | |||
| VmP7rQmKIo4JJs4rU2oTECGRqMGKhG2O4JEplhKzvGIVsqK9ivexm1xyOZIO | WsiSntkfJOFROE7gNvAQSAIZnst36hQXJc1TQmrSPY2VztYHCBqahBDoO868 | |||
| 14pgpj72E+PzDQ+r2xwwk2wyETEkdMz+YbeWsma6uDjSKUKThHwLXuCgif/2 | aoqFTyMpqilBoSVaNBcFSQYQBMFivZ83RU7KrpOs/zRH5DsvFfygokDnsurv | |||
| 9KntWx87GdQ+W8qq8jUo3tqHswezY14K/zoJBfd37z2UDN5NoiAIMrWyjXkn | UvOaJ2kMm7LKEDkTQ7QOhP/S+jJPnuaXdVEezWEPvCekpmOMNKFXzVmj5uyh | |||
| 6am98iUtLuE7HhL8l2KxXCVMh8LtQcuUu4ih2ekOilkDXcT6pomhmpn38nGr | ysxwhCkqzBGaFtmqtVe26q1KEU1OS/VAr6cdlGawPaSZqX+vWt4tDuNxX761 | |||
| Vx1DrCE/Nt/IrnZZQ4JAq0IyTjZLjl2qX6SUJCE+pu3KsM6iW+yZi/mRy6yB | L+FZWMGsT3+a46eN/sSneDylEMCMvkKWLBIIy8wVaaUnf6bS/sSSTAuF+yTV | |||
| e34acvwql1TsDQkxvRoEGdExtq4FHKYS3cl7C6mkn5hD7QsT67rF7LZWOpAW | YI13bLaBK4q5cXqVK8UEjU6dewGTg+eAuft1N1vNJkmuMBJ1oGcJQGhFN2bm | |||
| SHwXDhEA5TsJjHSqKhBBaxxfQcCQz89N4GF5h6Nkvd9XyUfQ38TpFzV5zLmr | jP0F+r0X4hUrxIXGzYRPq78oLRt/PSzsOk/zgt5f45x4Yy7RWDQpF9or6u2k | |||
| CEnTejnlvPjCIc5MrngbnLCovSep0JOYsG7uI8E/tFcrGZxAGUeYAAx2ylnq | 8mRy7OCFCerxm0FodlRZRnwf3uVMKhpYeNcJjSTmpjmc5yta2C4EDAe2CSdu | |||
| 6JI5my9ddsGYyKQzB/fzBw0XrgVAQjR4Axra5bMMRntcYyimzIFkYsJ84Dpu | Ancvm0+WCLUuGO1SoRoqOotq2xNnn7ujlQFawUarXXEqEmehiidcTL85fCa5 | |||
| i/EajCsrEvXF1Ga4dLnwtayNZgRw/3Ai1lkr3MJhMb4nbfDhKBGxainRBdR5 | z0YnBAnprCxU2DzTBFtfRRACuUkdBYu+ojVhvawmsBLfoZ5jVFIYayX/Tspp | |||
| hD4TidpoNLJVni6zuMYy6mv9Q6qB81+Ceabr5dLnNkMtztDmSvLm13M42iIM | aborgcDSORQqIorCsl4D0SFhx7AVA+dzLunHaZyZyMHLPE63of8KGDR3thCO | |||
| luQftVIJmHTdSolJCKglbggBz9Il/5YpmGS9NYsiCGY+HHbziSp9oCIyJNC5 | mPJ0TRLZJolfu2KY9rUkzTCvkZBrslgWfhWJRf1XFQ71PcAwZgDRpxsiDU84 | |||
| CFHSNdXODE7F4J+jVBHXcTBXdQi1jP03b56J/yR9NISnEFhNKvDTkgouVrrl | wbPpa+jVGwJ4A2YIcwE+3j8Fw6jt6m3gQVxTK+ofq8lkj7FveONyaAnlnqx5 | |||
| F7iN6zdLEqyLAjDlfTf0FnL9GCJyUTm7b5IIrREsbugpI+4auoTk4bgG3tc7 | TcSNaXOieZcuy9NE3UXdNJo/ossj4F0q9xae6fmEZpZ67NI77bt6wwFmyICp | |||
| sdOIbCtdQkGuaefTJxn96UyIhoYyGN+XPAolnysLdZqHxRK+6yLJbsbIYuQh | F9QEdeQmFO2GswLfSOljdElBUoH5+xqc9pZnwJzVl4omFSl0FLVPacE75w4+ | |||
| 3UQ01qzYqtk3UtnoJYIafhNHIqNItQneFTNr6CsKu4Gv6DpcAbUsZ0aGzCcu | cUCTmRbnghCS0Zjt1lWtytRhRiVGJXG2kkI3KAw8AxdzSrWq5lUEtcR5kPj0 | |||
| Idu941pEvmZQDlp67z51RK/sD2jZ3ZI1AoE2s2ck64yLvMBLDpCLEQVBBckS | fBCQ5vaTjmvgWZCk+QvS0q7kyPw5sEzsqgUQseYOAC2vYqCm0EpOo26YmrF8 | |||
| UVwjPuCZJss22UfxUUmE55L2XHPPMa1EVL0ZsXt6CcMyYhjst6D4wqJLN2+L | IF5zGNXmxP1FbpOghzJp0YuFTjUz0xDubfyjxFXn+Yso0kctcOE96ts4TJ7R | |||
| Tuxk4kCJ2HG7p1WA2WWUBLL6rxoSUMl/eLk52k7gGR6irIFRZn/wxHpHciWX | XBfNXbPnicdRY6IDzTpZYXRYjiJtLwmfdy7kmg8CbjHnWxsUgI362tdxIOtV | |||
| mmlgbthI2yKnaf33Ko43Acb06KBINkQS2KRuXqyrhXo7A5iw8UJp30AaTGWT | NUzl9TsXFMoPtK0Ef3hrNERZV6uQi1ITcaGu6/qd+zegf7ehEGAIeBcdOxyQ | |||
| lLhEwoQsEENrfCR7vhvRm3cAUJcICpMG2CFQlaGVlmt8jQ+vTKL6sGXPoToU | xkDikvdr8KEGccMLuqEwBB6/Tv0h3MnD60Y8Aq/asduu5XScNBx2euy75KOY | |||
| /7aDfpn/J1hd/8w0KyWlgmb0KWG4lSaE6GOm88BQeS986KvISNgP59SiugHq | RDO5FO30bXOQxZ4AJpa2XL1pv2MTMrD9pokhvvL27ETIMBJ1+xGQY7jLoB4w | |||
| kefKdalJA73HjJF75D5XZsX2q6iBXm/HXt5lGkwJvodeRdxBoiLJhB+IAteg | WF1gHHH7TCRIl2P+NAZcdvzm047/yNk/X14ypqg73OQkEw7IS2GHUNRuoxkQ | |||
| JQLCqajlW+XOXjXlM25FkIgU+9uQwU2R57JxNlh2B5NBNtATXMbz9J7GpBVZ | aTFVVGIplXCycQ1j4lk5NJ+9GMbaVqtGXOUasBkneVvuSpAED7SGJCkh83ln | |||
| vuyicMRndDozD8WuaQgyauGdPfIWfqjROx1tdRhzkdvZupBXwd9GK/jUC/KH | qnsjUEcc6Yna+4jp1aV0Knh/zRv4ZhyCGPFqZVGLLt2rOdTvQ2WtpiAkeYBH | |||
| 0NtqgpueOKyWIOob2MLP1JLK1DgBIvoW/QGt/8ki+YlvjH7w4B5y0rUvRfYO | qzvZ3bHIoOKMPFIWuWIxMpvmssN9sMdJBZ1e4mNkLqPkxqSlPMHbnKWOEcbU | |||
| EEHEuSZeqtHuOAS7OcUPcpqj7GS/tCkKq853cSjyChOcO3f8qjDFIH2ToJ4G | JgCC2UpiyqMjHhyTBo0ErhiFLDSvQHq/YC6BQsnd0dpSxj72QaT7ix+rSyZA | |||
| Bs2CrLs6FN8SUZNRjbheaohq1+cAKAtH1g5dsVLfzThWFbBuSD0cz4YeWE0d | ZjDJRFiN4DH7Hrq18+UeqQ9d7LF+3oIU2B/nfzx9bPvWu+WiTskdl1Sf1HBL | |||
| HOzJRnCSg8whPByd1oQEXNISwBglBgUjw99JpxLMzD3sHYoG444StsoVESBU | a7+ZfT27w0PhX/dDEfftu99IdPgaIRDbRGK/galy6PMgX1+TMWfDFLGdqMOX | |||
| 39snbWNCFqOGOp/gK0TUyOVsWldCCgym1szcj06sgZQ27T2a+2KIoKH2LQfz | ielYDBxVmMDvQqJQ0PrUh4r+gk26qpl5I49bPel0xepNZtuAjDaXNcQHlIFm | |||
| lVhf7A9cEeUzStwZx/BC2Mnux+t8yZxU7V8VkIvkwMlM3DeufvGcFl3tuIyK | nBsjKUEMLk26DLjnMbsyzIjpDHumYf5ilzVw/JyGjCTlSsr0YqRVTwbua3Su | |||
| QWRhO6QbEGAxHAH2fkXL5RKs8YZ4nT0+4SDdzDyYxQl6+u2Ob4vlqvYM+KKB | WdeyGsYRP5FaokMVYmKOVcRPrOsWsxualEXqxcAuZucTIL4Xl1unOgh8s+ha | |||
| aAso2lHhx0MuhY/M8WXBBpJCnaQZw/Xi7sEpInlNUUXp+SR5FC6eJa+sAezJ | RScQAOQDvxPY7t6YLVmn7KvBI+iGROcXdZGb3FUEo2m9nHLKBfSOrssWb9tg | |||
| iAk7To6g7kCT61liB8SqR9pt9PM4fD5cySM+1J5Vhc6awl2oiegKtr2CmvbC | zSctRgYVKRJs0Ml9jOGr9nIRgx0o2QgJgLxOOQEiOWNOFJFuP6F0P5NeDzif | |||
| XTswQNtazaDJLw7d+pJXVh0tc3bw09JiCj9zwEt2zTtJAcHG1xRhS+2W+Pz5 | T1SKOc0EkfZgaWrQgPcSDcK0pkbk85Eo9YD2QHTcacHLL84DGwgvZnSGq18L | |||
| L0+fvTu+S+hSWAaaQY0+huTMzOOZfVlUUmdPXmfRyYU3A6m1sRfrj+KBxFlw | XxPZaKgJ5w8DNTQ5Y4crn5PvN8Zuhzds0tPakJVGy2c1Qg7kR/Vzt0rSZZbW | |||
| V67xhfpDTjFEm7poDAfTKxekwmM990U5rDgcsz+3NA8h1DgmPRZRbEPxrmXx | FCX99UaFHsHNfhK8qCehhv17a399df5b4guTfC+TvIz6DVHDfDTYV+efpG4E | |||
| kS5jXde5OVyOKQoZ3QD798ieDGIjXOTMR0rkwXx3tWGNprPTX073tNgvtXwe | yDiC1Qkw7yRJSE68XifQbnvJhGBwPHjw4JuxTvspYo2jwqFxF3R8H/JXVVJS | |||
| g676W13101BgyrwT96nRf0PHUXdZR11LYczD9DlmxpFq+ocMj3OLbL2Ihi79 | SAJMeJMTZWXLetG3kvk/aF4o+XzB0wyFNDXSCfzMHvOoltrTL7ziV5+zYtYc | |||
| x61/+eaMr8NPHv31tg6aE+s0mi83saekOtqMTosrn9i/kytoT5uPH+uJfd+T | r1js4/+XFpuViVw7um7WbT97tRL/Spb6/v2rczQ3+UO4cAkifBSYSW6QRpqF | |||
| dPiZrOfSSQT6KTFwZV/MzLOs2cIWkVZaDzEmpk3ni+3j+1OdGAI8/HG4Dz8/ | V7BIibP5WL5+UBFHpaVzAYqEtKu9ib6X6MZEmcolqXyzo1zCZ1yLm0m6jBCc | |||
| hn6YKUcQ1nM6hP1QlB2kydOG0PuqrvLLrMoY4r/X68q+n9HPLwrQoD5wlu3g | nvro06AdwTDxjFOEr/sBboCTmSWpCIsCa8r7Lrbq4poBhC2S4n7fNyJ0i2DJ | |||
| XuiqHv4Wn/p5fTBgMU3uO+A//DzBT+aGtk+SHV03BVGkcFLu2EvlRp2Is2Cc | SV8Z8Wqhh4p8nHYE8EnG7FtDRgodQtG+FQWLRSP96UwIGYVkQd/qcxRvO1dp | |||
| zKx950gEvndtVSw+es3Ivim61wpxX9ZsryYVSN5PEiEIf+hIYq2QyNIwFBJ3 | 0GmuCobwZQGDBJAUWAw8hOQJx5oVq+eH1hY7BpAhG95JwzVJOM8EJxTLndB1 | |||
| cfduaL5Etf9QqVBsOOrPJC0pzJhi0C7MVBFIgj55tiY7xz6tP+HfJD0qOgrM | JcwGEUHH4Qrol7JnZBH43A6oKd6/V6QuOVVztA+Bd9C5dx2hLbtONOd9yToO | |||
| rZb+fk7Mm9uzBXmb2e8FffCC9DVOSZZ6mdHffyeJ8jwjksO/a1fan7OSNqr4 | rXBmz0h6G5f4zHYcTBSjAKIXIyQzNOIxO9PEgk32Vjx6pJTkkiCy5m5+NBIh | |||
| T7rNf0MnbBH+PFv0ZJ5j17dg4wrJ4Q1pbnyAvEWe2TPcMv6mO8hoQYwVxKAA | 9yb23jlyFnEY0XSPtfCQLMydm7dFJ3YfEaJENzppVyULZgebpNqot08dqKrL | |||
| /tEvQO7PRVmSV8CNxRHSkYnFvZ1l5e/4d0Q8+DNiD/i4jrBw3mOGA/4qNkSL | HB9ujlYcYD7HECzSy+wTd6xHJSez06gsE8VGejtxRov/XRWMTVjjcOtATNas | |||
| fyf1tWxlo7PObeFtvMyahiiDU7I5EeaGvz0vNoRIEv3ml9nTWVyszooghLSi | B2uTAmgxFxZqvcdlwmYJqfURQxjZJkMcE0YTIua8WuOjfvP9CO28QYuigGY/ | |||
| 3nkiHZKbdOMStBPz3sQ3iiGMaDOsYWbxuKs5rQtR9YxDb3Ruks3NLljzr6fP | 0bZyiRmDBnVc5GW8M3qSJNMuew5soPqrjRoTV//5PzON4Euqvhk9JQi3Uk0+ | |||
| jfn8JIPg+2L+ygHKFzyu8Yl9R+TTOimd0hgHFAtt94lg4mCJpJ79+Kib5BIU | eOwt1kBcpGNIQz2NfBPjj5vVNOS49JGnjytDBv0pPXiMHCZ3BGOybK+ED9TV | |||
| iJ3+gemhxyCsfyxIhaGUlaM5B8bH/Mctz4k6i5P039H3jPg82pIvfXTv/uOj | duy62A39z8Gg1vNIG2woezLhBdFLNc6DGNqQ7fLRcgs0tU8zrigXJz67scCP | |||
| 29jvPXcPX+WVXNtuP/Jmb1ERrf5GEuGE70dsmZXXteGDR0dLsnZb3vYNWYm3 | myLPZeIsGixHo+excAd+kPPhYY3xK7Hn2O5mJ/lodyaWmwyjNkmzs9kDb7eG | |||
| /vW2nRdeL97TUlsLo/Xa9nx8+/tu/K5hlkUemAkM3lHb06atD8tq7I4MP5iR | rObT0VTHIZf4UnwzXA2bmNieB1DxmwietDYGWKIXBt30enhaxRuTB9WKAdG3 | |||
| H169eYZQ0j+UAJErJKvBjQI/fMIBtdI/FHUPcVvJNR36+PExo/iZFIfYUISj | qBNt/SuLwSu+hdzXX99FEk/ti4G8WU8r4uA8D9VI1S/HBzknCug05+a5B6mg | |||
| zlZsZc+ua88ToiZr/3EKVQImvK6F792/K4dRHhwG9ozrOK/tKD8+4qO8rhbl | SSRqvk+jN5dYltyHwY8KCwMseBAH0ViKWZDRUocKGEJqshURChnaV9oUKy6U | |||
| LNxn+4MO0LnOS/pzEPYgQdjQr8BFSdr7xPUfLfcvomLTNztdGxD35NbItNbC | OSSLiK5YqUfCOJYX0HRIRtyZxW5hGm092r0O8RyOy4WIWrJbEzIWBoWhDFEi | |||
| vuJ3ydkja3V9R1VCx/kS91l7D+hhLdcP7rM00lzfOUWInuY5l8D5CGcYdKIB | UBAyzPhhw8+ZuYu5Q5J1WlnMxqYCAojqmx5JQx1Bi1GroUHAJNfD2bSuBBeI | |||
| FZ+TRJyFg6VDnOb6kHEvuffT53vdm9e31cn3SdW7P7IePW92Eh/iBgrxdNYk | atfM3Et2rN7BdthCYu6zx4KYOtQizBWxkdTMvSQqYhS5M455BF+qPYxv+BRj | |||
| kOii6OZ6Dppva8xRSArvr01EPfpOqB8bvVuZWIHWqCLMWcUkxxWXW8SlCf97 | qdq8LICR8IH7yf6YkybHOs445eUxo43RWXgMDQfMEj94Jh0dU3/4nfvsdZ6Z | |||
| WKWvnKCV63wLM2MBFySJMEUJSJ3FQBwQen7gzRVw/68Ndfe/E3WPGHWJp6AN | r2dpNhO9u+eTGjRO0QyrZApI2lGW3Ddch5ao5cuiyuOqBzkZ4Whx7qAS4bqG | |||
| 81xLIrXM14csEORURDanH6OJm36gLvIbXUPuY3fpso9SnQXcNlEim4cy0ve+ | jNOYyzSItSdAkZgNZDpBLsR2hrFkJGlpJlI2UAQS6Em9tT5Og43xNB7wng60 | |||
| yaw9GqQn34FrftIJn5ixED6c0IPjztX/+e//O66tva7bgIS/6jY2h27jId/G | KpRWF+5CNUVXsO4VxLTn61r+CLTWzC9NFeAol68OYKnRMlH7DLtR4tm4e6hG | |||
| L5zJhyCOG6qSkGVov4SavS5wVUb6AaFsvcuE4WFII7D9J1lDkIvfRbsPBFso | 6SXZauPzLzGlliq+f/+Xx09e37kt2SCjTXe4/2JFlPRwZn8sKqlzK5aQa9Js | |||
| dB1aGvd7VkEbUe7v2sTUvYffCe8Jw/sbwmdoFLYvqhXH3VG0grQAXfLTZ+8Q | PGJam/pl/Fb8IrEXHJVrfKFczMAI7tMuaVXK6Mq5+7A6z30CI8sMx5TPXd9i | |||
| gy2JK/ps5a4N1LvfCep9JcR4kF1crhwN536q8bRrg/X4O2G9x7CSV621DTz/ | SCCNsYy5E+tQPGuszTLHE9dFFqMa7/Acg30Dj5/UhAz7HOPjS1Vr9B04/fn0 | |||
| mv3Lg2OHr427if5ux3pH5jccH9+/rg2OH6qXeYlyfrsNQyCv7QT3dYOobOra | iAgb99uvankzxmyvjXvMp+0K0JDLl5x3uzqJuIWOmNOnuF6GZNOvcs+MW2Tr | |||
| 1n6kvk3aMVUkbUxw9K9twx+/k24kZiBDhu2Nq2p0blwXgD+KnfCOOxLjEm+M | RXKpwW/X/+Wjd2gc//LWX2/oLS6io75//z65wOUDbHp6dEpCpM1o68AA//Bv | |||
| 7EXtKho2ymvb7VGwd7mrq3OfZJrNJ5E9knErXWrBXd9lfK/AuStMvHUl67tl | ZCba0+bt29o/edMT3/iJFOvS7fkZiI6ePyYKr+wPM/Mka7ZQVBr/q98QLiyZ | |||
| 8emaQHl8Vy0OKeKMNMVcxxRe7re3hbFwSAXR19cEyyPx+IYBOLFNEyyayBFM | zhfbh/em2nsVYPr0bR3//sjm4q0uYdH1HL35fynKDjkk8vBxQ4fxrK7yXVZl | |||
| CtmuCwiRKi+LT4gTy3ic1uOdS3izbdHB/rhW/nz8mLd9EYI1semXJj6ubcsD | 6Vb+Vq8r+2ZGI1wUlfsAnSqOcZbtGzyzflK/vRY/+IuBoP/irpc/sL3j39P2 | |||
| fsQ4t6FiwIspiYxy+zP5/Fc+MgD4vamUu8dHt2dYW+ROrtGrdhZlf3xmgTWt | SFvRLhwkPGpx+DE15o4NXi62TagTus0MDXHfv+abHFxbFYu3H6J4ZeUfLRAK | |||
| hvu5a4tHBU+fXxuCHrJ9at+GGfn2881oYL4x+41gw1z+qJg13KX/ta9k902+ | MYTWrPQO8j69xSXsFJbVLQlDlHy1AhSfkDCRdnIKnTxQYhUzxDQYz2TBhvAR | |||
| kskK4d50asB8GO2vs8J8AnwjUeBh9v/Bl22ss2Fqvva2j4YpGknGQ/1EdmAy | fJOngkYpDsnzJ2vSnezj+l18Qsypgn+VFLk2PH1KHCK3ZwsyabPfi/D4B9IK | |||
| SzIeShxq+CRvixJLv362X6I6eqODrnb68ztC15LnW/ihdVwWdRjuvUWHtLhC | AAmyB8osPP0b8YmnmSCyPqldaX/KSlpSlTwkfPg3dAYqRg/PFj0ZB3GVL8FN | |||
| 9ujRQ4IMM6XgeAuv2r2CWl8kacd1qhgn5TLmcU7r3BkyoneiSbtr38Koepr7 | KuT0bNo6vvsSYcE8Q50w444+pUPNaDrcIoSWjskHP9OB2Z+KsiRbJQ9PR8cp | |||
| 4P04proMpWHDxjMFUCbocMuiXKvKMHrAYZYm4yWd/82AeN4Ik5j4ux/aoUHb | D/E1IWX5e3wyRFR9OCRbeXjmCNbnPfpzxmfFhsjibyR8l226pLPObWEt/Zg1 | |||
| ajM2OgcKAiF5C0JIa3mROaAOuFi7cuvnrycd0hjYPe4W/vyZ37yDEqKQZI8S | DaFmeH5OJ/2CWFx887zY2MdNxtOYn2ePZ2mpEjPQ4K1LOiUSKpMsINwTf6RY | |||
| WT4qhlKPgy8QkAGtyKj9z3/9vzByjJMR+CB+vwAf1fhJ3y/9GzDSWLR2kNSL | KybFLVzZhK4ZNbRGbow/p3El5dA3YLfvryXd2I05zB7zTd/bNEoRmqn4t32A | |||
| IgtDlPZGJml8xuyd5TkIUDIiRVwnIlPp+Zr4xQtph5lJLgUVSKeBF7SSk6na | 0ucFCyuHOKUFvRsVGsxj33gtWfcq4EacibGx/NHbHNZZ7LCt6fCjpjJG1FFQ | |||
| M1o0JM0QQaNXoUXBD+cWOTtULLSAkGdjS5lbUhASgsR0EnMApKgI3GkVXRiB | UnSFBPWNhxv0K40J7HA2+rGzQ2ft6KoAHen0p9cEqiWXw/imCXpr2bE1Hwwa | |||
| pq97GTpahDjkdRQzJN27aNKQzMsfDneDY6oyxIeHF9EV3dmidkUYI5n3oyWl | FUNd1YMH36CcDWlbO+njSms5cC17d6Ede2xRfkp6a7id5GZUCm4mHTjXPudR | |||
| KWhadqdWhRvPbZa8lsHgw8WiJ+ze8rPg5EHp3NReeB7nHFPAbRFEdwh9C2HU | DVdOm/fFm3UZvCNx4pkuUOrtOMdRjlRrdegDboXJcBk2B+aFDJsMkRbIv33V | |||
| CB5zEB6Wbxd0N9q/EtU9pJBB+DBMjVZd8GjbcGVcjoQye25Ow/aQ6R6QpARH | xnxuq7nbiAaTCWIG3dKDueMLDSPoAAu08PfNmQcJ1TN7WmkBQIgCEj/BtU4w | |||
| yZLrVpAlZuWJgFvJyb6Ch9VYUptaxrXk10FNwoB/HnBVj9sxkhepmGHSJI86 | oFXPbFMOvNLLnWDoHG00Lq3TIApAWFqhzD5W+jvtQs4b1XUYlBAe88JpSkC9 | |||
| Sfs1ZBphNEqhWs3sa+7/6Ld7zZKy2IjohyZRkdYbUlJMVp4U1FrbOz6b1Dzm | KLJQcHlQXqlNhs3BTp4C/eS2miK1k6RhNR8SdysdZqOZwZHA+j5VP1dwZTJO | |||
| j6tvB2lZNGmv+usqiJJJ+u6YYQSx16bSr3RRS61zFaVk0RWTYMa/VWScxQqv | exJLSqoNoTPCzy2MXRaJ9HINmSEeNO6YKy6egUEU7GzaiTmypCQY4tSDFAqm | |||
| tMkihRPm43A56f7barTa89a791P5522AxO0vJmrZm9Djncxe91OFZJZUmH8W | 9RaRGMsR1JCm9VfnvZ0oPNnigFSGG//keALcR/o5eOj4DbMhi2BNuZebbiQ4 | |||
| GgHi0esvwnBcHbCUtOH73J0XB5UlBGiTok6k2H8lT1J5L7bCu6aelxjQGCq4 | iYoVKekZ2HDH1gH4diX8RGjR5+QCnrqaqhtgybd1TUL/bK4nrcdR6sGNBb6B | |||
| 3vlu91M/1lmNHPfFv89Ff3Bo7vP4xUyjvjU/YdsXgB4QX5NRthYSEOMmSYVC | qqjtXF40jGRLC4CkfOGgIcRPyfYSjy642CdvViromXn5OBIJDfbTfuq2//m7 | |||
| 9ZtkdsW05FYjoQPaOFwFPQGW5VKKSueaS2cK2mxRCFJyccUV9pEk/hEu9VPd | 5tjfz+FeL463cxf2uJMTrraQODaXyNJCbm5h9gtHNYMTFnf8EKvVW6mVm27c | |||
| UaLHHTf8S+6t5F67gl8ZdMUEO3vuGxsmsY9ySI9YLRcdiJf+GAR3mFDA6lHr | vFRu0kKrw3qx6AkS133TAflQcoS15oJ7mqbM44bo4Tf9GdxMD8EcXQ8LxQsi | |||
| +kNbmJQF2bQoazT9MpoB0KqhRSsNCINKQYdC1jRZJSVW03jYTqjvbX2B7lcP | a01mSWzG4cpw3rymBhbrAVKYEVL8GfQ3Yzz4PNw3sVXOJ6KAfc4pIf32IDFX | |||
| JE0pHea9C3elb2NCETQ+ZNLmd5bC7fbtNhKKLtAxUZTltO11ZE08sktqBjEr | BhsxzZiQLLJ+Q+oNsyWPD1qvdrB9bkfCJMHhiyhri2ZYGvG8CoJoMrygJDbx | |||
| Cnrun32x+FjuWJDJfCpMD+ZG+qDOfCWQNNocKnHjFrhN0bI5PEIotxxC/3H3 | 83qYZDBd1BIsqhL9D4kyQ/rQuytGkif20MwSdSUUY7Ir/vBKFPWUX3/9Zir/ | |||
| GhR0sDHY662lT1lMezVYLMtfxuSzr2MLdX3S0V+hlOhAO/mS3+GpvYp0+xi7 | vIElcUaMSXL4JvR5J229fQmr1C2HUvsQUE27ev8QGstpNe+g6sO3APXipLIE | |||
| z4pheEPGgCqZJ4eX46HYbfSutOENTaSFsioaHudNPULgHyDYqK8QPRMk0i8z | AM1a1MSBw3tfBhFM0TJfN/W8RDuQ4AJ77YsrTn1jRFWP3Qd/a4i+cKxzYj26 | |||
| GZx8CLfSBpTsR2vo+J1cpjDLaiBtdOWqSYlrHwbtbBibMZ/L+Rc8VuzKIYg+ | L2qUyea7pnrn+RHxNxnG9VmCorlJvZlDcTSDisJpydlHggc0cTgK+gIkydKs | |||
| B9A67vIadub+nECAksXhdxrxWwKroWFba8vh3Vjvc2UDQaq9k/ITNzGhBrz1 | 0vxiifAj7xZWcMk25SWatVgZsDB8Y2O4ODlzgd/kZEvOvpPclUuaJdhzHyGe | |||
| 71YJg+r0pWbyTeerOEnkaxkGCSGCdId3sFzspkhsKEvKIFCM7KvS1xCl3O8v | pFe8HdNDrLraI/KW+0Twh4IY1q40MBoyxSbK9wderVGvlaTkpFU1nUaKAINK | |||
| Z292sh1m4Ry+JxyL7x5mwv7NT5QS/Ux/NVblzUXfNsi9S2PD64QOmrB+bhtO | ghAvmWpZJQlS04OW6QppCW5cuSEJ7ndoeSzUNbzzB+oFHjJq83WTyG3zaQty | |||
| KWVOkI1hoL6deiQuMm1Jk3ewYDxj9CYH9j/rardhfVUWeD2PEIlcJy3gPmUL | o1GBkDPZs9O21/rItD5cnK4oTIZ284+e7Ntyz4xMiqGl+1nScTm4QSRh4ZiP | |||
| 18zDqNCtaMThTWkH0Tp33NwU0PoHkBqDwq3Fs0QB1Ut+VVZqdvL4PB4cqQfa | kLPiNkXLhtQIoJyFCCHICW1Q8IKOCg8y/SiNGdgoVIXXMv9lSD65GlrwPkoB | |||
| 9/L0PRij6cxaAKmvUEIJbHhdyl73rtynSt49Ye+nToXBguqDzwTsOdrh0Npr | SQUPypH8cikgEFaJED46T7NgiPcuRFBJ7wL0OoefcHSFW7wHiKRQViWdCryh | |||
| Re6uOWrBwYLkpVEIaKMY/dCgMPS0yZzoidXhYuF4YeLzwWnQYirghYc8Tugq | wH3DPoqwSaohgs7E0neZdH47BltJpxjMR2NorWcubeRkNKA28nTV8Y1jj1Wd | |||
| oe79SF/f3+qcTAwJ9+eiFfrKnw1hHmRzfvmj2RwyknxjoppJTNbyqhHvHusr | G4ZmSuey/wXXsF/ab8MHrlrH2TJxZk5wSBAQWKm3F1YxfVuDcjCMrTfVs4iN | |||
| HPG67quG3srobdJ8HFCopu7TmohQGjdQzTlMcJT5NGgUIru98i/CY+7l8tMf | qvEMiYlTQBA8a7lurcpjSwRQe+P0l877wInfax4KcSBa5h7Xelzsp6gcVXqU | |||
| OMzUwKuBoEcM9Scs8Vu1QHOG1Zp37pDbe31I8Fd1C37SDyhDB3/dVzyoDYML | jjNoDlENr7cZkr4/mSMtxELd5fFDwrb44KEjHB77RNHQt8RVS0duxPm4Neet | |||
| pQgLHfWYMCLDuYe39nkNHIrUYQFzcTGG6UpB5TDiwr+D74yEhuu4iZ4n8PPt | YRuuqTlq//gOAdilVHOBMYZ+tGxcChQXmSb2yL0eaASS9OZm30Vd7Tcsrcoi | |||
| yAtf6zYIE2kyj3sODggThv2922KKbc7z80m9M+h91en73zSI3MgMA4I2tInH | az2KyHkaNLnMFq6Zh540W5GH8Tauo3DlBpkJXD8BqulSONf4kkv/fJQ7vZOV | |||
| U6ptsDvltTi07o0zRIm4jP9G8HkTs0FtmYrNbs7sRGMWHIIx/I5ifnFP1mWC | WyW+6y6x1ZIe7yzSIJ5DNrvEe0O503Xp4hEbhSAkLOzZb5gUHe4QQVA9Mdt1 | |||
| RQndaOu26EP0PtCaMv+kLknND1XFPGJdOnaFBmfJ9NA9B26YAzLwu4kMDYSA | w9fUthKMh3abFaHB+glXsROzOMHtvaywocGglpFqu1hkaZ94tVKvYfPrwVex | |||
| fMk+zxpJXwU1TBvjiVvRG0OM0gtIOlRt8AtIZoFVWp1DyNfICJPeXW3R2Rsa | MSF9dxlX9o6E/ESsk3XR5IMirnZd7yqjvY4PbiwMUr5ecjLtUMH32w14c+iI | |||
| LLNgObrmh2EhosQ5vkzb6DvlN30RHncbe5Yi4P8/bKZTTY9/AAA= | 8Tc/SJ1w2nRN3ex6CTDCNOGGhoPMaa0BQ6NxEXMHktXXk4eWIeoum2kS6BzZ | |||
| W8it1vVA0q3Zw8iOvcENUKjwR/j0WB8A3wVuogNp/4Cw39DV7WjHN1HQuCkS | ||||
| nVm8jPHKk1PHY6v9cNAN0O9SR+grv9uDazxeHoNUrIXwTkWoNXKSw3M4epNK | ||||
| 4gh9dMz3dnDYMx0mlEkPjsTiYs3kLDJ/jTahQVo5jzPSgf7QSV16RgluHjmt | ||||
| G8gnj77VtNn4JdzKn5OOKz1dBkiZHJRegfIlCOyLENcfJ6wxXf1pmkJq48fO | ||||
| 6iP0ZBi5PpOUUjK6Zn+uq+nP4cqutGI7ucv+sZ/l/TWfn6rGHstnuQQjuohZ | ||||
| Hev2W3dZlzhpV0n6OzvVq6l7tybZIqk7hC1PY9MjKepGqhiJmMpfGslqCMcO | ||||
| v2I/dwMHDdRVNFH5DkP8vVogPcdq6gMnSh5cJBC8tjoFf+l7eqA0qe6lty56 | ||||
| /Uj7AJQKoXBSKmnjDZfejgi5CrDjOXyM7nMSg4qVe/6+yjPSflzH1UHcCJlP | ||||
| R27UrtugFUn1TJp6ckQr4rW/cVu0fcu5jTEZKbz0vur0gkRtGNZIbVbWxfqX | ||||
| tK+jDdaz3G9D456cIVLC2RwnwX03MH7UIqvYecDtY5LyMYeABAQxkyBC1gJF | ||||
| CV9oIr9o9UiBoTFFlahJZ3ExJMxtSSV/W3BwNmi4deCGiuWNyRVNibmEMIjP | ||||
| 2+ASyuFdabFFB7epSO4MMIovQOnQ3IyvIJgFUmm1dQ8fIwNMUrg1UWvgD2Vr | ||||
| ogsRJt9BAlEVmPXiU9iiLElOXm+K5NxzT1IH/aOHl0TjSE+eI7eem9K9ICO0 | ||||
| Jyw/sayXxuRTaXlkzro9LeAZzFwbcg12u92MBp+6HJyJMw1avMfW8C1gw91b | ||||
| 1wo/x/8qdY6/sofwyPXS6WUT2vTJhqtwfTKotgsPF1yilzYUU39n9raBkwO3 | ||||
| LMlsib2b3lbdSIrBLPVj1z04BpotEI+SyPGyzFbSi6HGfYioMgvXl+q9Jxz5 | ||||
| kHZ8uN1EC9gAZH+/ypz7gKiXV0Tg/wVCeEEEVYoAAA== | ||||
| --> | --> | |||
| </rfc> | </rfc> | |||
| End of changes. 95 change blocks. | ||||
| 896 lines changed or deleted | 635 lines changed or added | |||
This html diff was produced by rfcdiff 1.48. | ||||